mojira.dev
MC-312430

Falling pointed blocks deal more damage than before

This issue was introduced in 26.2 Snapshot 6.

Falling pointed dripstone and sulfur spikes deal more damage than they did in 26.2 Snapshot 5 and prior. In 26.4 Snapshot 3, icicles also use this new damage calculation.

【 Steps to Reproduce 】

  1. Open a new creative world in Java 26.4 Snapshot 3 and switch to Survival mode.

  2. Place a support block exactly 4 blocks above the player's head.

  3. Attach a Hanging Icicle underneath it.

  4. Break the support block to let the Icicle fall directly onto the player.

【 Expected Result 】
The icicle should deal a moderate amount of damage, reflecting the short distance it fell.

【 Actual Result 】
The icicle deals a massive 9 hearts of damage (18 health points) from a low drop height of only 4 blocks, nearly one-shotting the player.

【 Additional Information 】

  • Game Version: 26.4 Snapshot 3

https://medal.tv/games/minecraft/clips/nG5BKN3SmhdAgci-c?invite=cr-MSxUTHIsNDk2ODY1NTU3

Environment

Official Launcher, Vanilla (No Mods) Operating System: Windows 11

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 5

This affects all falling pointed blocks and was actually introduced in 26.2 Snapshot 6:

Oh…. i never knew that….

This issue has been reviewed by our team.

Please add new, relevant information if it helps us understand or reproduce the issue. To show that you’re affected, use the vote feature rather than commenting.

If a fix is implemented, it will be listed in our official changelogs.

For major outages or urgent assistance, visit the Minecraft Help Center.

This seems to be yet another floating-point-arithmetic-related bugs. The damage of a falling dripstone is min(40, floor(ceil(h - 1) * size)) where h is the fall distance, which, in the case of four-block high fall, should mathematically 3; but versions post 26.3-snapshot-6 seem to give an value slightly bigger than 3, resulting in 3 * size damage instead of 2 * size, which, given that size is 6 in this case, gives 18 versus 12 points of damage.

I did not find a way to read the fall distance when touching ground, but fall distance at the tick before touching ground is available:

image-20261013-135159.png

Left is 26.2, right is 1.21.11. The left value is slightly bigger than that of right.

(That the size multiplier turns out to be 6 seems another problem, but that should go to another report.)

I ended up writing a small Mixin patch that reports the fall distance used in causeFallDamage: (accidentally wrote “fall damage“ in this image)

屏幕截图 2026-10-17 160724.png

So it is indeed rounding error. I think this may be fixed by shifting the result a little to keep the values away from rounding points, similar to how MC-167125 got fixed, which incidentally also relates to fall distance.

Hraklisss

(Unassigned)

1703663

Confirmed

Expansion A

Normal

26.2 Snapshot 6, 26.3, 26.4 Snapshot 3

26.4 Snapshot 7

Retrieved