mojira.dev
MC-312837

Despite block sound set twisting_vines is extsting in game, but no block use it

Since 26.4-snapshot-3, the block sound set twisting_vines have been existing in game (client.jar/data/minecraft/block_sound_set/twisting_vines.json), and no block use it. Because of its ID, it has a high probability to misleading player into it is used by twisting vines. The fact is twisting vines use block sound set weeping_vines, not twisting_vines . You can check the code to verify it easily, but I provider another ways to see it below.

All ways to call block sound set is hardcorded, so I think any of existing block sound set should be meaningful, an unused block sound set will make player confusing, cause game waste resource.

Step to Reproduce

Load the attaching data pack 'block_sound_set.zip', and place some twisting vines and weeping vines in the world. I set block sound set twisting_vines use slime sound, weeping_vines use anvil sound.

Expected Result

Twisting vines will play slime sound, weeping vines will play anvil sound. Looking at their ID, this is the most reasonable result.

Observed Result

Both twisting vines and weeping vines are playing anvil sound.

I don’t have any suggesting for how to fix it. Maybe removed block sound set twisting_vines, or make twisting_vines used by a block ,like twisting vines, it depends mojang. But right now, the situation can cause a big mislead to players.

Attachments

Comments 1

Thank you for helping us improve Minecraft! We saved your files:

[media]

wplx

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

26.4 Snapshot 5

Retrieved