mojira.dev
MC-54194

Key press of simultanously pressed keys not recognized

Moderator note

Not a Minecraft bug, this is a hardware issue.

Keyboards cannot necessarily record 3 random pressed keys at once, especially Laptop / Notebook / Wireless Keyboards have different keyboard matrix / CPUs compared to desktop keyboards.

There is nothing you can do to solve this except for switching to another keyboard that doesn't have this issue.

Cannot move left while holding the TAB and LSHIFT keys at the same time.
This occurs in all recent versions of the game (1.7.X, Snapshots)
Java 7 on Windows 8.1.

Linked issues

MC-6406 Cant jump / Cannot press multiple keys on the keyboard at one time Resolved MC-11456 When holding down W & A at the same time you can't attack Resolved MC-18629 can't press 3 buttons at a time Resolved MC-26877 Movement bug: Cant use more then one key at once Resolved MC-30716 Jumping and pressing 6 without use Resolved

Comments 8

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit

Cannot reproduce.

Incomplete without further details, e.g OS, Java version.

Confirmed for me in 14w18a, but shift+any arrow doesn't work for me AT ALL, due no doubt to the fact that I use the keypad arrows to move. I never noticed before because I use the keypad for crouch, and every other button too (isn't that the point of gaming with the keypad arrows? enough buttons beside the arrows to handle everything?)

So doing a PROPER playtest (setting the movement and crouch to defaults): cannot reproduce. But for anyone using the keypad for movement there's a bug there.

I misstyped when I made the post, it's TAB not ALT, sorry.

Ah ok, retesting...

Confirmed in 14w18a (yes with default controls). Why only left is affected but not the other 3 directions is beyond me.

Yeah I don't get that either.

Not a Minecraft bug, this is a hardware issue.

Keyboards cannot necessarily record 3 random pressed keys at once, especially Laptop / Notebook / Wireless Keyboards have different keyboard matrix / CPUs compared to desktop keyboards.

I have a "normal" 104 key keyboard and any combination of three keys out of TAB/LSHIFT/CTRL plus movement keys is working here fine on Windows 7.

UnexpectedTaco

honestly I'm a bit sure that this is an issue with minecraft's recieving of inputs, because this is an issue for me as well

Tom TS Sawyer

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 14w11b, Minecraft 1.7.9, Minecraft 14w18a

Retrieved