[MC-69387] The "/item" command cannot replace items within jukeboxes

The Bug:

The "/item" command cannot replace items within jukeboxes.

Steps to Reproduce:

Place down a jukebox and stand on top of it.
Replace the jukebox's "container.0" slot with stone by using the command provided below.
```
/item replace block ~ ~-1 ~ container.0 with minecraft:stone
```
Inspect the jukebox's block data by using the command provided below.
```
/data get block ~ ~-1 ~
```
Observe if the jukebox has anything within its "container.0" slot.
Take note as to whether or not the "/item" command cannot replace items within jukeboxes.

Observed Behavior:

The "/item" command cannot replace items within jukeboxes.

Expected Behavior:

The "/item" command would be able to replace items within jukeboxes.

Attachments

Comments 20

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit 2014-08-25T13:33:49Z

WAI. A jukebox isn't a container because it has no GUI.

marcono1234 2014-08-26T08:57:23Z

But isn't the definition of container, that it has the possibility to contain items?

marcono1234 2014-08-27T16:14:21Z

Hello?

user-f2760 2014-08-27T17:10:42Z

it is a container, but jukeboxes are not yet supported by this command, can confirm

marcono1234 2014-08-28T12:04:53Z

So is it a bug or not?

10 more comments

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit 2014-08-28T12:17:40Z

Container (Google Dictionary) - an object that can be used to hold or transport something.

A jukebox isn't a container because it has no GUI, and for the fact that it can only support 1 item at a time (a record disc).

marcono1234 2014-08-28T12:19:26Z

Your argument makes absolutely no sense:
Container (Google Dictionary) - an object that can be used to hold or transport something.

Does there stand anything with:

needs a GUI
can at least hold 2 items

No, it doesn't stand there!

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit 2014-08-28T12:24:22Z

need a GUI

Yes, replaceitem needs a container with a GUI to work (Chests, droppers, dispensers, etc.)

can at least hold 2 items

replaceitem also needs a container with multiple storage spaces.

In regards to jukeboxes, they can only be modified with blockdata.

marcono1234 2014-08-28T12:28:59Z

Sonic, I don't understand what your problem is, you are inventing there all kind of rules for containers even you have disproved all of them with your quotation before!

marcono1234 2014-08-30T11:24:43Z

Mods can you please reopen ? 🙂

marcono1234 2014-09-01T12:16:53Z

Hello Mods?

user-f2760 2014-09-01T14:48:29Z

it they don't respond, they don't change it, so it won't be reopened, even if you ask they 100 times

marcono1234 2014-09-03T14:21:13Z

I am just not really sure why this is works as intended...

marcono1234 2014-09-21T13:04:08Z

I would still like to get a response from a mod...

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit 2014-09-21T13:29:18Z

Forgetting what FVbico said yet again, I think:

if they don't respond, they don't change it, so it won't be reopened, even if you ask they 100 times.

It appears the MC Wiki is your friend when knowing about this:

Other blocks which hold items but don't have inventory GUI's (flower pots or jukeboxes) can only be modified with

/blockdata

http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Commands#replaceitem

marcono1234 2014-09-21T13:52:29Z

Like it was probably said from many mods before, Minecraft Wiki is not a official source from the developers, they are also people who collect what is known, I guess so then this line

Other blocks which hold items but don't have inventory GUIs (flower pots and jukeboxes) can only be changed with /blockdata.

Is only a realization!

marcono1234 2014-09-26T20:51:17Z

Alright, maybe they will still add this feature eventually

Avoma 2023-05-30T07:45:36Z

The behavior of this problem has changed slightly ever since this report was initially created. In the current release and snapshot of the game, jukeboxes have a "container.0" slot, contrary to what this ticket was previously concerning. The problem here is that when attempting to change the "container.0" slot of a jukebox, the command claims to be successful, but in reality, it's unsuccessful. I've updated this ticket accordingly to reflect this new information.

user-f2760 2023-05-30T08:10:24Z

That issue is included in MC-260485; why was this reopened? The design had changed since its WAI, and the problem described didn't apply anymore.

This should not have been reopened and MC-260485 should've been used instead

billysjoberg 2023-06-08T12:30:58Z

Fixed as part of fix for MC-260485 The "/item" command cannot remove items within chiseled bookshelves - Jira (mojang.com)