mojira.dev
MC-75431

FallingSand with water are invisible (MC-64222) But NOT RESOLVED in MC 1.8.1

This bug is tagged "Resolved", but I have just test in the last Minecraft version and it doesn't work... We have to create new issue otherwise the bug will persist and I think it's a large bug.

Thanks (Sorry for my English, I'm French)

--------------------------------- MC-64222 ---------------------------------

Upon creation of a FallingSand entity, if it is a water or lava block (minecraft:water, minecraft:flowing_water, minecraft:lava, or minecraft:flowing_lava) it will not render at all. The shadow still appears, and when it touches the ground it will still place, but it is a minor visual bug regardless. It can be reproduced via the following command:
/summon FallingSand ~ ~1 ~ {Block:water, Time:1, Motion:[0.0,0.3,0.0]}.
It will spawn a block, but it will not appear until it touches the ground. It helps to be in third-person view to witness this. This bug is specific to fluids only; sand, stone, etc. still appear to spawn and appear fine.
I am aware that this was reported previously as MC-1300, but it was incorrectly marked as resolved. Either the fix didn't work, or the bug resurfaced sometime between 1.4.2 and 1.8. I will continue testing in 1.7 to see if it's snapshot specific.

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media]
migrated

The Ticket (and not the "Bug" itself) is considered Resolved.
As a Mojang Dev saw the entry, and classified it as Working as Intended. How can it be clearer : That's how it works.

migrated

I haven't all understand ...

It's not a bug ? Since the 1.8 Minecraft version it doesn't work.

It work as intended ? it's intended to have a bug ? I don't know ...

When it will be resolved?

kumasasa

MC-64222 was resolved as "Working as Intended" by @unknown

migrated

Mathieu added a comment :

  • It's not a bug ? Since the 1.8 Minecraft version it doesn't work.

  • Cela n’empêche pas le jeu de fonctionner, et il n'y a aucune raison apparente que cela devrait etre autrement, donc non, ce n'est pas un bug.


  • It work as intended ? it's intended to have a bug ? I don't know ...

  • Partant du principe qu'en aucun cas dans le jeu c'est quelque chose qui se produira naturellement, vu que c'est le joueur qui joue avec les commandes pour modifier l'environnement, alors oui, le jeu fonctionne comme prévu.


  • When it will be resolved?

  • Jamais je pense. C'est un développeur officiel qui est venu commenter que cela marchait comme il fallait, il n'y a donc aucune raison de modifier un jeu qui fonctionne comme on l'a codé 😉

migrated

Resolved doesn't mean "Fixed". It means a decision was taken. In this case in MC-64222 the decision is "Works As Intended" (see resolution) and in this issue the decision is "Duplicate" (see resolution).

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 1.8.1

Retrieved