Affects all very short effects (those that only last a single tick) - this most likely also includes saturation, see MC-19648.
How to reproduce
Prevent you from regenerating automatically, for example by using the following command:
/gamerule naturalRegeneration falseUse the following command twice
/summon Arrow ~ ~5 ~ {damage:0.5d,player:1b,Potion:"strong_healing"}You will see that you only take 0.5 damage but don't get any health back
mojang nerfed all the time of all the arrows. Im ok with that... but I find out that the instant health/damage got nerfed as well. and healing 2 hearts turned to be 0 hearts :|
well... sorry if I sound rude but... 0 heart? lol its nothing! Im shooting my self with instant health arrows and get damaged more then healed. :|
mojang... I think you should nerf the instant arrows but not that much!!! :|
I guess its just a bug...
Code analysis by @unknown can be found in this comment.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 8
MC-91840
Tipped arrows with instant effects don't apply effect
Resolved
MC-93130
Healing Arrow
Resolved
MC-93959
Harming tipped arrows do not do extra damage to the target you are shooting at.
Resolved
MC-97697
arrows of life and damage void
Resolved
MC-98010
Arrow of Healing, Arrow of Damage
Resolved
Comments 18
I have tried hitting myself with very low powered shots and with no armor a normal arrow does 0.5 hearts of damage. The same is true with healing tipped arrows and they do not heal you at all even with healing 2. The harming ones also do 0.5 hearts with harming 2. This means they make absolutely no difference at all or it's so small that it isn't displayed on the hearts. Either way it needs to be fixed so harming does a bit more damage and health should do less damage or maybe even heal more than they damage.
Can confirm on 15w47c.
I have tested the instant health / damage arrows on myself, a villager and a zombie (undead - reverse effect).
They do the same amount of damage as normal arrows for both minimal-charged and fully-charged bow.
This also applies to the potent version of these arrows (healing II / harming II).
This appears to still be broken in 1.11.
I have tested this for a while with a healing arrow on a zombie.
I observed how the effect works when you dont charge the bow all the way, but it doesnt work when the bow is fully charged.
Can anyone else confirm/deny this?
This issue is a separate bug introduced with the 1.11 fix, explained here: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-107856
Confirmed for
15w44b Please include somewhere "tipped" as they are "tipped arrows". Restructure the report and remove all comments. And remove the environment.
Please include from MC-91840: