mojira.dev
MCPE-124291

Powered rails become powered after relogging despite there not being any redstone powering it

Steps to reproduce

  1. Load

[media]

Expected result

All powered rails at Z = 10 should be off. You can see in the world's thumbnail that they were all off when the world was last saved and closed.

Actual result

Some powered rails at Z = 10 are on, some are off. It seems to be random which ones are on. If you break and replace blocks at Z = 11 the rails reset to how they should be powered.

Note: this may have the same underlying cause as MCPE-105749.


When trying to make a collection system using minecarts with hopper and powered rails, i noticed that every time i relogged into the game, a random off powered rail would become on and get stuck on until i fixed it like do in the video then they go back to how they are meant to work by being activated with a redstone torch under the 5th rail (which is the closest powering source). I don't know what is causing it but the redstone is basic and works faultlessly until relogging where the bug happens so i think there is a bug with the game. The video should show everything, that is why it is quite long but i have had to cut areas like writing signs etc and reduced its quality as the file was originally too big but not being a good editor, it is quite rough around the edges as you will see in the video. 

Video contents in order:

  • How it should work

  • Relogging

  • Show the bug/issue

  • Quick look at the redstone (even though it shouldn't be the culprit but might be a bug with the redstone and not the rail itself)

If you want the full unedited version, let me know and i will try and respond to you asap as i want to build the farm but can't until the bug is fixed or i can find another way around the problem.

Thanks

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 6

When I tried to play the video it only played audio. Could you try to capture it again? You could record the several parts as separate videos if the file size gets too large.

Please also take a look at MCPE-105749 and see if that describes your issue.

Hi GoldenHelmet, that strange as i uploaded it as a video but will try splitting the video into multiple smaller videos to see if that works. Will do this over the next couple of hours. Also, don't think it is the same issue as the one you ask me to check as my issue occurs during relogging in but not saying that it not linked as it could be but i don't think so. Thanks.

Hi GoldenHelmet,

just added 8 new videos, let me know if you can access them or not as they came directly from xbox capture so it should work. Here is the order i recommend you watch them in to make to slightly easier to watch and understand.

  • How it should be (in off position)

  • How it should be (in on position)

  • Redstone Involved part 1

  • Redstone Involved part 2

  • Logging out 

  • Logging in

  • Aftermath (end powered rails...)

  • Aftermath (having to break block...)

The video are very short due to file size restriction and were hard to show as much as i could in that short time but i believe it shows everything but if you need help trying to understand what im trying to show just drop a comment and i will get back asap. Thanks for looking into this.

 

Thanks! After viewing the videos I was able to reproduce the bug in a small test world.

Hi GoldenHelmet, its great to hear that you were able to watch the my videos and reproduce the bug. It lets me know that it not just me having this issue. I don't know why it happens but i get the same results as you did and i hope there is a fix to it in a future bug-fix update. Thanks for looking into it for me, i will have to design a new collection system design to fix this issue unless it gets fix before then.

I cannot reproduce this with the test world in 1.20.

Luke Boulding

(Unassigned)

510141

Confirmed

Multiple

Xbox One (OS version: 10.0.19041.6737)

1.18.0.20 Beta, 1.16.220, 1.18.2 Hotfix

Retrieved