mojira.dev
MCPE-136040

Screaming goats don't scream as they're falling

Expected:

Screaming goats scream as they fall long distances

Actual

Falling screaming goats only scream when they hit the ground and die. If they hit the ground without dying, they don't scream.

Comments 1

Thank you for your report!
Unfortunately, this report is Invalid.

In real life, some breeds of goats scream to stay connected with their herd. It's not an expression of terror as it is in humans, it's a method of keeping the herd together in terrain where it's easy for them to lose sight of one another. You can confirm this by doing a web search on "Why do goats scream".

I believe that in Minecraft, goats spawn with a random chance of being screamers, and goats that are screamers scream at random times, not for any particular reason but just to add realism. So they wouldn't be more likely to scream while falling a long distance than at any other time. Unless you can give a convincing reason based on information from Mojang for your expectation that they should scream while falling, this doesn't qualify as a bug.

Note: If you meant this as a suggestion for how to change goats in Minecraft, this isn't the place to do that. Suggestions should be made at the Feedback site.

Miles Grover

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Windows

Windows 10 Home 20H2

1.17.10

Retrieved