Duplicate Recipe Warning

The error I'm receiving is reporting that I have created a duplicate recipe, however I have not. Because both of my recipes are shaped, they should not be causing this error. I'm guessing this is a bug because Minecraft should allow these recipes to exist.

This is the first recipe:

{
  "format_version": "1.19.62",
  "minecraft:recipe_shaped": {
    "description": { "identifier": "pokeb:trade_holder_right" },
    "tags": ["crafting_table"],
    "pattern": ["ARR", "RR "],
    "key": {
      "A": { "item": "pokeb:pokeball" },
      "R": { "item": "pokeb:aluminum_ingot" }
    },
    "result": { "item": "pokeb:trade_holder_right", "count": 1 }
  }
}

And here is the second one:

{
  "format_version": "1.19.62",
  "minecraft:recipe_shaped": {
    "description": { "identifier": "pokeb:trade_holder_left" },
    "tags": ["crafting_table"],
    "pattern": ["RRA", " RR"],
    "key": {
      "A": { "item": "pokeb:pokeball" },
      "R": { "item": "pokeb:aluminum_ingot" }
    },
    "result": { "item": "pokeb:trade_holder_left", "count": 1 }
  }
}

The expected result should be that both recipes can exist because they output different things. Because they have a different shapes, it should allow a different recipe.

However what happens, is that it throws this error, and doesn't let you create the recipe in the game.