mojira.dev
MCPE-188512

Parity issue: /place command lets you place only 2 vanilla structures: Trail ruins and trial chambers

The Parity Issue:

/place structure only lets you place 2 structures from the vanilla game with /place structure without add-ons, that is trial chambers and trail ruins. In Java Edition, you can place any structure that exists in the vanilla game with /place structure

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Run this command: /place structure minecraft:trial_chambers

  2. It works, and a trial chamber generates ✔

  3. Run this command: /place structure minecraft:stronghold

  4. It does not work ❌

Expected Result:

The /place command would have let you place any structure in the vanilla game, just like Java

Observed Result:

Only 2 structures from the base game of Minecraft: Bedrock Edition can be placed with /place, perhaps because of the way that these structures use jigsaw block generation for these structures.

Note:

This does not count the use of add-on structures.

This issue specifically talks about the vanilla structures that exist in the vanilla game.

This is a valid parity issue for these reasons:

  • Command /place exists in the latest development version of Bedrock and Java Edition.

  • /place was added way after the Buzzy Bees.

  • There is something different to /place in Bedrock than Java. /place structure in Bedrock  lets you place only place 2 vanilla structures. /place structure in Java lets you place every vanilla structure.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 2

Can confirm. Via a QNA, a Mojangster stated that only the Trail Ruins and Trial Chambers use the new Jigsaw system that is accessible via the place command and other related APIs.

[media]

TheMightyDark

(Unassigned)

1338147

Confirmed

Multiple

/place, experimental, vanilla-parity

1.21.92 Hotfix, 1.21.80.27 Preview, 1.21.60.23 Preview, 1.21.60.21 Preview, 1.21.50, 1.21.51 Hotfix

Retrieved