mojira.dev
MCPE-27040

2D Redston T-Flip-Flop no longer working in Windows 10 Edition v1.2.1

The attached screenshot shows a compact 2D t flip flop design that worked perfectly prior to the 1.2.1 release, but now no longer works. It now triggers, but won't stay in the on position. This broke several redstone circuits in my build that would be very time consuming to replace due to having to redesign entire (large) circuits because of space constraints. I would appreciate it if you could fix the issue preventing this design from working. Thanks!

Attachments

Comments

Auldrick

Your design depends on a sticky piston not retracting a block when given a 1-tick pulse. That's a difference between Java and Bedrock. The devs have already said that this works as intended. See MCPE-14851.

Maybe you can replace it with this Bedrock-design T flip-flop? It takes the same input pulse and fits in a small space. It's also cheaper and silent. Unfortunately, it has a longer delay (4 ticks).

[media]

Note that the comparator has been replaced with a repeater.

migrated

The piston timings seem to have changed. This seems to be happening because retraction happens sooner (compared to red stone update). Related issue: MCPE-27090 seems to be happening because extension happens sooner (compared to the red stone update)

migrated

Thanks for the comments everyone! Auldrick, thanks for the alternate design! That worked perfectly!

migrated

The original design also works in 1.2.2.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Windows

10.0.15063 Build 15063

1.2.1.1

Retrieved