mojira.dev
MCPE-34737

Trading allows a trade to go to a full stack and loses the trade and the traded item

If you accidentally try and add a trade to an already full stack the trade is allowed but you lose the trade and the traded item. Bug. The trade should not take place at all. With the new bug/design feature no longer allows multi trading but instead have to stack each emerald separately when you have a mountain of veg to trade, accidentally adding to a stack of 64 emeralds is easy to do.

Attachments

Comments 5

I came on to report a similar bug but add to yours as ours seem symptoms of the same problem.

Used to be able to place say a stack of iron to trade and click to trade and just keep trading over and over until you don't have enough remaining to stack to trade. 

Now, intermittent crashes of the game if I try to quickly retrade before putting bought item in my inventory.  (I think it used to automatically go into your inventory but now it just floats around?)

EDIT: now remember bought items did float but also could accumulate and you could keep trading further items.  Added more info and video link to the related bug report: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-32635 (Thanks for creating that bug report Morgwenna)

Also sometimes it doesn't count the items you've leftover to trade, as per picture uploaded.  (In the picture, just traded some iron and the emerald I bought is just floating there and it's not counting the remaining iron to trade)
So remaining items to trade need to be moved out of trading square and in again before counted to trade, e.g. move the stack of iron out and in again before it offers an emerald to trade.

Should add I'm also on version 1.4.2.0 but playing Bedrock Edition on Windows 10. 
First noticed this only yesterday and not sure when it started.  Mainly noticed it just with farmers as I was trading multiple stacks of farm items.  Today I tried it in another world and with other villager trades and items (both worlds I tried are old worlds from previous versions btw.).
I've had the game crash a few times if you click to trade again very fast after just having done one.  It crashes to desktop.

(I think it used to automatically go into your inventory but now it just floats around?)

Whatever the situation with this bug, trades should automatically go to inventory. I mean, that is how they should code it. Put a stack of wheat on the left, and tap/click/press A on emeralds on the right to pump emeralds into inventory. It should not "pick up" the emerald from the trading UI for you to manually place before doing another trade.

 

Good. So I am not the only one then. Yes, sometimes the emerald is not offered unless you replace the stack to trade. You might have 64 somethings to trade but the emerald is greyed out and nothing will happen.

This was resolved in 1.9? Working fine at the moment.

Morgwenna

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Tablet - iOS - iPad 3

iOS 10

1.4.2.0

1.10.0

Retrieved