I have the exact same issue. It happened when I fed both the seagrass but one turtle was in the water and couldn't fight against the water current and missed its chance and now when i feed them I get the exp but no eggs.
Everest Withers
I have the exact same issue. It happened when I fed both the seagrass but one turtle was in the water and couldn't fight against the water current and missed its chance and now when i feed them I get the exp but no eggs.