Paul Manning

So had this problem in the past - recently tried again, failed, revisited settings and allowed create clubs -. Saved and now working - realms creates a club! 

So another year on and my girls wanted a Realm again.  Paid for a 2 player Realm, one can get on, other (eldest) gets this error STILL! Is there realy no fix for this? The privacy settings via the family account pages are identical across all the accounts.  Appaling that this hasn't be fixed yet 😞

The settings referred to are over here - https://account.xbox.com/en-GB/Settings (Xbox One "join multiplayer" is the one you need. In our case that's set for three of us in the family, but only works for two of us and we can play each other. So basically wifi/broadband speed eliminated. Also (included in attachments) I get different errors for that person depending on whether the setting is ticked or not - so the Minecraft App pulls the settings OK. So my guess is that the Realms piece that's broken somewhere... I've also elimanted the PC, as the same user gets the same error on more than one laptop - including the one that works for me...

Just checked and I logged the broken account into another machine (My Surface Pro) on which MC Realms is fine for me, and still no joy. Can only conclude xbox live settings for account are corrupt in some way? Btw disable all privacy and security settings and see different errors (see attached) change then back and back to same problem

Ps Minecraft 1.2.10 on Windows 10 1709

I've got this one two - Windows 10 + MCPE. Have a family arrangement Realms works fine for me (Dad) and youngest - can play each other fine. Eldest the settings don't get picked up by the app. Have deleted/reset both minecraft & xbox app and still no joy.