Steven Robb

Assigned

No issues.

Reported

MC-30877 Crops (Wheat/Carrots/Potatoes) not popping off in light level 0 Fixed

Comments

Steven Robb on MC-82298 2016-10-20T23:19:32Z

Just checked in 16w41a and it's still an outstanding issue. It's never been addressed since reported.

Steven Robb on MC-30877 2014-03-01T23:56:33Z

Thank you for re-opening this issue.

I don't know what the original intended behaviour is, but it would be good to get that cleared up. I would note that planted items popping off in low light levels has been in the game for a long time, and used in many builds (semi-automatic farms, etc.), so it has at least been shown to be useful.

I'd also not consider comparing anything in Minecraft to 'real life' as a valid argument for behaviour being one way or another—since when could 1m cubed blocks of stone be made to float with no visible support? =)

Cheers!

Steven Robb on MC-48944 2014-02-20T10:03:10Z

Behaviour still present in 14w08a.

Steven Robb on MC-30877 2014-02-20T09:59:46Z

Despite being marked as duplicate, and the duplicate being marked as resolved, the behaviour described here remains the same, and has not changed since first reported. Wheat does not pop-off in light level 0. This bug remains in all snapshots up to and including 14w08a.