mojira.dev
MC-107671

Observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires

The Bug:

Observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires.

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Build the setup as shown in the attachment below. 

[media]
  1. Place a redstone block on top of the diamond block and watch the redstone lamp closely as you do this.

  2. Take note as to whether or not observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires.

Observed Behavior:

Observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires.

Expected Behavior:

Observers would not act as transparent blocks with redstone wires. Instead, they should act as solid blocks.

Linked issues

MC-109165 redstone power will not travel down an observer block MC-109656 Redstone dust energize put on observer, not energizes redstone dust connected when this (redstone) is a block below MC-111067 Detector Block Signal wire BROKEN MC-114113 Observer Blocks acts Transparent with redstone dust. MC-120422 Strange behaviour with redstone going down side of observer MC-141717 Observers not transmiting well the redstone signal MC-146715 Observers are not blocking redstone MC-154684 Observers block redstone signal passing through MC-154902 Observer not conducting redstone bug MC-158694 Beobachter Übertragen kein Signal über die Block-kante MC-158777 Redstone signal does not connect when traveling from an observer to a lower block. MC-171809 Redstone Dust on top of an observer clock doesn't power Redstone Dust on the side MC-182019 Observers do not conduct redstone signals downward MC-203545 Redstone bug observer MC-259569 Redstone signal wont go down from observer MC-260918 Observer erasing redstone signal

Attachments

Comments

Anon Ymus

Might be intended; the observer is treated as a transparent block also in that it doesn't conduct redstone.

NullPointerException

Might be intended

marcono1234

But you can for example place torches on it which does not work for transparent blocks, or does it?

[Mod] redstonehelper

It works for glass blocks and for blocks with a solid top face and probably a few others.

Meri Diana

It's also the same for Glowstone and bottom slabs, stairs, glass, pistons, hoppers.. all of which are transparent blocks.
As the Observer is (at least partially?) transparent as well, my guts tell me that this should be WaI, but it'd be certainly good to have input coming from the professional tech community, if this behaviour for the observer (do NOT remove it for the transparent blocks I attached as pics here please..) is more benefitting or the opposite in their contraptions.

mxblue28

What's weird is that redstone can travel up the side of an observer, but not down it.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w03a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w05b.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w06a.

Avoma

I am able to confirm this behavior in 21w41a. Here are some extra details regarding this problem.

The Bug:

Observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires.

Steps to Reproduce:

  • Build the setup as shown in the attachment below.

[media]
  • Place a redstone block on top of the diamond block.

  • Take note as to whether or not the redstone lamp is powered by the redstone wires.

Observed Behavior:

Observers act as transparent blocks with redstone wires.

Expected Behavior:

Observers would not act as transparent blocks with redstone wires. Instead, they should act as solid blocks.

NullPointerException

Avoma

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Gameplay

Low

Redstone

observer, redstone_wire

Minecraft 16w39a, Minecraft 16w43a, Minecraft 16w44a, Minecraft 1.11.2, Minecraft 1.12.1, ..., 1.21.2 Pre-Release 3, 1.21.3, 1.21.4, 25w08a, 1.21.5

Retrieved