mojira.dev
MC-112245

Music disc sometimes continues playing after being taken out of the jukebox; audio can overlap

The bug

If you insert a music disc into a jukebox and quickly click it out again, the music will continue playing without the music disc actually being in the jukebox. In previous versions, when successfully reproduced, the following error would appear in the launcher log:

[media]

How to reproduce

  1. Get a jukebox.

  2. Put any disc in.

  3. Click as fast as you can to get the disc out.
    → ❌ Music continues to play without the music disc being in the jukebox

Related issues

MC-132958 Jukebox Will Not Stop Playing MC-139438 Jukebox Glitching out in Multiplayer MC-151385 Jukeblock Music Duplicates MC-155507 Spamming jukeboxes will cause a music disk to keep playing MC-155931 Music disc overlap bug MC-159148 music block MC-160347 music disc overlapping MC-161997 Music disc audio plays twice if inserted as the disc is picked up MC-164862 Jukebox still playing MC-174228 Jukebox music gets stuck and plays over its self MC-174675 when using a macro you can make juteboxs play without the box when breaking it and sometimes duping music disc MC-177800 Jukebox won't stop playing music MC-184169 Jukebox music overlaps and keeps playing MC-184426 bug with jukebox MC-192497 The new music disk keeps playing MC-193940 Pigstep audio overlapping MC-194619 Jukebox playing when you break it MC-194737 Music won't stop (and overlaps if you spam a music disk) MC-195928 Music is still played on jukebox after disc is removed or jukebox was broken MC-196806 Music disk plays when it should not! MC-199288 Multiple discs are playing at the same time, even if there is no disc in the jukebox MC-199698 Jukebox stil playing song, when disc played and removed within the same tick MC-200115 jukebox bug MC-200713 Minor bug with music disks MC-201870 Quickly Breaking and Placing Jukeboxes and inserting disks causes the Current disk to continue playing as well as overlap with prior plays. MC-201918 Jukebox glitch: Music playing without a disc MC-202696 Mix and play many songs with one Jukebox MC-202827 Glitched jukebox MC-203135 Spamming Music Disc Will Cause It To Play Even After It Is Removed MC-210851 By playing a music disc repeatedly without stopping the music begins to play without the need for a disc or the jukebox block. MC-216264 Jukebox Phantom Music (Reissued) MC-219353 jukebox play music without cd MC-219408 Music Disc Glitch MC-222530 Jukebox Bugging out MC-224100 Music disk play when there is nothing MC-224379 ghost music disc MC-226418 Jukebox Spam Issue MC-231256 Spamming music discs in a jukebox can play multiple instances of the song MC-232106 multiple jukebox sounds MC-233440 music disk MC-233789 Jukebox bugged when spam clicked MC-233984 Annoying jukebox MC-234265 Bug found when using Jukebox in Minecraft MC-234768 Multiple cd dans une jukebox MC-234790 If you left click on a jukebox very fast with a disc the music will still play even after removing the disc or destroying the jukebox. MC-235582 jukebox Bug MC-235927 tune without the jukebox MC-237284 jukebox plays with no disc inside it MC-237872 Jukebox music overlapping MC-239449 Music block still playing disk on destruction MC-239524 Jukeboxes dont stop playing MC-239562 Jukeboxes play sound without disc in them even after the jukebox is destroyed MC-239937 Jukebox still playing music after taking out music disk MC-259119 Juke box MC-259253 When spamming right-click on a jukebox with a music disc, the song will eventually play with no disc inside MC-260224 Juxebox keeps playing after hopper minecart interaction MC-261550 Music Discs can sometimes continue playing even when removed from the Jukebox MC-261786 Jukebox spamming record MC-263178 Music discs continue to play after being ejected MC-263271 Spamming Jukebox makes music discs play multiple times MC-265133 Jukebox sound bug (NOT A DUBLICATE) MC-265236 Juke Box music disc glitch where the song keeps playing when the disk enters the hopper minecart leading to being able to play multiple songs at once in one jukebox. MC-268685 通过使用连点器,将唱片快速放入和取出唱片机,唱片掉落,但歌曲仍持续播放。 MC-273330 Spamming hard enough on a jukebox can cause songs to overlap. MC-276793 The jukebox is still playing after I remove the disc MC-278446 Music Disc keeps playing when extracted with hopper minecart MC-278852 The music didn't stop after the disc was take out from the jukebox MC-297312 Disk problem MC-297954 plays music without the jukebox (minor) REALMS-5124 Phantom music disc

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media]
Misode

Can confirm for 1.11.2
I had to try this multiple times (20+) to reproduce.

EDIT:
After testing with an auto-clicker I managed to reproduce this way faster. Even clicking the jukebox, giving it a block update or breaking the jukebox won't stop the music. When pressing escape the music stops but continues when going back to the game.

EDIT 2:
After quitting the world and reloading it, the music starts from the beginning. When the music has ended, the music just stops and no music disks are duplicated.

EDIT 3:
When clicking the jukebox with another music disk both sounds are played at once. This allows you to play 'an infinite' amount of disks at once.

migrated

I think you clicked so fast that the game couldn't manage to state if you put in a disk when clicking or not so it just returned null at the stop function, as seen in the launcher error message.

migrated

It would be probably a Won't Fix.

I agree with José; it is a game issue.

violine1101

Can be reproduced very easily by changing your controls settings so that you use a keyboard key instead of a mouse button for "Use/Interact".

migrated

i found the same thing still not patched in 1.15.2 using a macro it works but clicking is very hard

migrated

Confirmed for 20w20b

pulpetti

Confirmed in 20w28a

ItsTinay

Confirmed for 1.16.2

migrated

Can confirm for 1.16.3rc1

migrated

Confirmed 1.16.3

migrated

Found a way to stop it! Whenever you did that then make jukebox volume to 0% then 50% its stops

migrated

Affects 1.16.4 Pre Release 2

Avoma

Can confirm in 20w49a.

migrated

Affects 1.16.4

Koooper

Affects 1.16.5, music stops if you go into another dimension or in the case of servers, disconnect and reconnect.

Koooper

Affects release 1.17

migrated

Affects 1.17.1

santinocavazos

Affects 1.19?

migrated

Can confirm that this can also happen with the new 23w07a snapshot and the interaction with hoppers making it some what more likely 

migrated

Still an issue in 1.19.4. It happens 99% of time for me

migrated

Happens in 1.20.1

Mr_Tech41

Happened to me on my friend's server also. Both of us realized that when this happens, BOTH OF US can hear the disc, even after the glitch is performed. My guess for the cause being due to something similar to how ghost blocks were made...? (IE: Client vs. Server thing) This is mainly due to me having issues replicating it in single player worlds specifically.

migrated

i was watching a YouTube video about something (unrelated) and they accidentally created a redstone contraption that can basically spam this bug but it requires a specific timing to get it right 

migrated

Also found found about this bug in a vanilla 1.20.4 server. Affects 1.20.4 Java Edition

Neliz_

Added video demonstrating the bug.

migrated

Happens in 1.21.1 and can easily be reproduced with a hopper minecart. 

N_0_L

You can replicate the glitch even easier by adding a dropper that puts the disc into the jukebox and as the last comment said putting a hopper minecart underneath, letting you automatically trigger the glitch every time. (Tested in 1.21.4) 

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Platform

Normal

Sound

Minecraft 1.11.2, Minecraft 17w17b, Minecraft 1.12.2, Minecraft 18w03b, Minecraft 1.13.2, ..., 1.21.1, 1.21.3, 1.21.4 Pre-Release 1, 1.21.4, 1.21.5

Retrieved