The bug
Lakes can generate through villages.
How to reproduce
Seed: -95289255
Coordinates: /tp @s -173 71 -713 -40 30Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-140267
Lakes Override Village Generation
MC-140306
New village house bug
MC-140334
Villager Building's Get partly deleted with normal terrain generation
MC-140337
Normal villages are not well generated
MC-140359
18w48a Village spawning issues
MC-140512
Plains villages get cut off by lakes
MC-141154
fences in animal pens dont fully generate
MC-141579
a Villager's house has a hole
MC-141701
Lakes and Caves Conflict With New "Village & Pillage" Structures
MC-142453
Floating village components
MC-142506
Some village houses are not created properly
MC-142829
Villager Houses Spawning Incorrectly
MC-143867
House Generation Error
MC-144913
Surface ponds mess with structure generation, etc.
MC-144922
Tall Village House Generates Without Wall
MC-145636
error generation of villages
relates to
Attachments
Comments
migrated
migrated
Can still be reproduced in 18w21b. Seed: 961751257
pokechu22
Can confirm, still an issue with that seed (the village in question is at -460 72 -198).
migrated
This bug is most noticeable in superflat with water lakes on.
migrated
Affects 18w22c
migrated
Affects 18w48a
migrated
When water is under a house, the house is generated without a layer of 2 blocks.
gaspoweredpick
Confirmed for 19w09a. This is a problem for iron golems since they now spawn in every village. There shouldn't be so many water lakes that could trap them.
gaspoweredpick
Seems to be fixed in 19w14a. I have checked many villages and they didn't have any water lakes within the vicinity. I have also checked out a village on super flat in the "Overworld" preset, and the village did not allow any water or lava lakes within a certain area.
pokechu22
Any idea which version it would have been fixed in? (Have you seen it happening in 19w13b?) I tried using the seed in the description but the new village doesn't have a lake or blacksmith in that area.
gaspoweredpick
I looked into it by downgradind one snapshot at a time and it was actually 19w11a that fixed this problem. I even checked a superflat village in 19w09a and it was the only snapshot I checked recently that had water lake generation in villages.