mojira.dev
MC-126906

Buckets cannot be emptied against blocks with the state waterlogged

The bug

Water buckets and lava buckets cannot be placed against blocks with the waterlogged=true state. Note that for chests, you already need to use shift-click to place water inside the chest, so allowing shift-click to place blocks against waterloggable blocks does not entirely fix this issue.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Place a waterlogged=true block, for example a slab:

    [media]
  2. Right click on the top face of it to place water:

    [media]

    → You'll see that nothing happened.

Note: This also affects double slabs, even when they are not in water.

Linked issues

MC-126959 Cannot use water buckets on double slabs MC-127014 Cannot pour out water on doubled slab MC-128126 unable to place water on stacked slabs MC-128720 Double slab doesn't allow you to place water NEXT TO it. MC-128820 Can't place liquids on double half slabs MC-129653 I can not put water on a double slab MC-129676 Can't place water on the side of stacked slabs. MC-129917 Water Unplaceable on Double Slabs MC-130562 Strange Water and Slab interactions MC-130631 Unable to place water on double slabs MC-131675 Can't place water on top of top half slab MC-131994 Placing fluids adjacent to double slabs doesn't work MC-131995 Cannot place lava adjacent to half slabs or stairs anymore MC-131996 Cannot place water adjacent to a block that can be made waterlogged MC-132096 Can't place water bucket against double half slab block

Attachments

Comments

Irbis

Water is now placed IN those blocks. But true, it should be able to place ON them WITH SHIFT pressed. That would be intuitive.
Also this bug affects lava bucket.

Phssthpok Pak

The lava bucket cannot be used to place lava in or against any block that can have the waterlogged state. Clicking and shift-clicking both do nothing.

Alexander Freyr

Confirmed this also affects version 18w16a

Freakin_Sweet

Yeah this is troubling... it's strange, especially for double slabs, where water cannot even be part of the block given that it takes up the full 1 m^3, but you still can't place water on the block, on any of its six faces.

Xavom

For lava bucket in 18w19b, I cannot place lava adjacent to and when clicking on: stairs, (double) slabs, fences, walls, chests, trapdoors, ladder, sign, item frame. Regardless of shift.

The chests are always opened.

For ladders there is bucket animation.

For Item frames the bucket is placed into it.

This is inconsistent considering that shift is used with placing adjacent to the targeted block, so as to not access or change the target.

muzikbike

Affects 18w20a

FusionLord

I have not personally checked this bug, but have noticed that the screenshots are taken in creative, which buckets don't empty in creative anyway.

Alexander Freyr

@FusionLord The problem is not that the buckets don't empty, it's that they don't get placed at all. 

muzikbike

Affects 18w20b

Cameron Arnott

still can't place water ontop of a double slab in 18w21a

muzikbike

Affects 18w22a

muzikbike

Affects 18w22c

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre1

ItsMartin

Still an issue in 1.13-pre2

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre3

Hugman_76

Please check the Affected Versions before commenting; the change has already been made.

user-f2760

I just added it 🙂
EDIT: no I didn’t, confused it with a similar ticket.

bugsbugsbugs

This bug is still in the bedrock Edition MCPE-59107

Hugman_76

coschevi

Confirmed

waterlogged-blocks

Minecraft 18w10c, Minecraft 18w10d, Minecraft 18w14a, Minecraft 18w14b, Minecraft 18w16a, ..., Minecraft 18w22c, Minecraft 1.13-pre1, Minecraft 1.13-pre2, Minecraft 1.13-pre3, Minecraft 1.13-pre4

Minecraft 1.13-pre5

Retrieved