I created a recipe using a water bottle in the center and 4 vines (above, below, left, right) to create one slimeball. when selected from the recipe book the vines were moved but the water bottle was not. The recipe itself still functions as when I manually placed it onto the crafting grid it created the slimeball, it seems like it's just the water bottle is bugged in this regard.
Linked issues
Comments
tryashtar
Everything i could find regarding custom recipes though said that as long as the data portion of the item in question in the .json file was left empty it would use any item bearing the same ID, shouldn't the expected result be that it still pulls then? And if not the bigger issue would then be with it not pulling and not putting in the red faded item image players wouldn't know the recipe unless you have a reference somewhere else in or out of the game.
tryashtar
Check the issue I linked – the recipe will work, but it won't automatically move the item over if it has NBT. This is done to protect your enchanted bows from being used in dispensers, but it has a host of bad consequences such as this.
Hmmm marked as won't fix. Fair enough, well hopefully a small change that puts the silhouette in the crafting grid when this occurs then?
This is because the recipe book doesn't like using items that have any kind of NBT, which water bottles do (
Potion:"mineraft:water"). I guess that makes it markedly similar to MC-123002.