mojira.dev
MC-134540

The entity data of spawner get lost when player far away from it

The bug

I placed a drowned spawner with drowned spawn egg and command,then I changed the data of drowned made the spawner spawn a drowned with a trident by using "data" command. But when I far away from the spawner and return, the data of spawner got lost and it spawn normal drowned.

How to reproduce

  1. Place a spawner

    /setblock ~ ~ ~ spawner
  2. Right click this spawner with a drowned spawn egg

  3. Use this command to change the spawned drowned by this spawner

    /data merge block x y z {SpawnData:{HandItems:[{id:"trident",Count:1},{}]}}

    → ✔ It will spawn drowned holding a trident

  4. Move far away from this spawner

  5. Go back to the spawner
    → ❌ It will spawn empty-handed drowned, not drowned holding a trident

Note: it won't happene if I use this command directly:

/setblock ~ ~ ~ spawner{SpawnData:{id:"drowned",HandItems:[{id:"trident",Count:1},{}]}}

Comments 5

I cannot reproduce this in 21w08b.

Is this still an issue in the current release (1.16.5)?

Still reproducible in 21w15a. Seems that you have to manually move far away (fly or walk) for the issue to occur.

This has nothing to do with travelling away from the spawner and returning. The SpawnData tag only stores the data for the next entity (or group of entities) to be spawned by the spawner, hence the provided /data merge command will only cause the spawner to spawn a trident-wielding drowned once (before 1.18, anyway). For the command to work, the SpawnPotentials tag should be modified instead.

The reason the /setblock command functions as intended here is because the SpawnPotentials tag is empty, so the SpawnData tag gets copied to the SpawnPotentials tag.

Yep, this was never valid to begin with, and a user error.

To avoid these kinds of things in the future, use /data get to see what's going on.

BLack_Tea_RGO

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

(Unassigned)

Minecraft 1.13, Minecraft 1.13.2, Minecraft 18w47a, Minecraft 18w47b, 1.14.4, 1.15 Pre-release 6, 1.15, 1.15.1 Pre-release 1, 1.16.5, 21w15a

Retrieved