mojira.dev
MC-157404

Breaking blocks that can be instantly destroyed slowly breaks the targeted block behind them

The Bug:

Breaking blocks that can be instantly destroyed slowly breaks the targeted block behind them.

Please note that this is not a visual glitch. The targeted block will be destroyed as normal once the breaking animation on it is complete.

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Obtain a stack of short grass and switch to survival mode.

  2. While looking at some dirt, constantly place and break the short grass in quick succession.

  3. Observe the block breaking progress of the targeted block behind the short grass.

Observed Behavior:

The targeted block behind the block that can be instantly destroyed slowly breaks and shows block cracks.

Expected Behavior:

The targeted block behind the block that can be instantly destroyed would not break at all.

Linked issues

MC-157191 Harvesting and planting crops repeatedly and quickly breaks plowed dirt block MC-157235 Auto crop farm destroy stage MC-157758 when breaking redstone repeatably bock under starts destroying stage by stage MC-157845 Breaking bar not resetting on farmland MC-157921 block breaking bug MC-161201 Breaking and placing a flower repeatedly will put block in a frozen state. MC-162266 Breaking instantly breakable blocks gradually breaks the block behind MC-162938 placing and destroing string causes breaking block under the string MC-163073 Farm block starts breaking unintended when manual farming while using both hands. MC-163281 block of dirt breaks during farming/ блок земли ломается при сборе урожая MC-163841 1.14.4 bug MC-165440 Instamining a block doesn't reset block breaking progress of a block mined previously MC-167634 Visual Issue when trying to mine mushroom block MC-168286 Makes a gliched block state MC-171400 Dirt block breaks MC-171844 When you break a torch, you can keep the damaged texture MC-172651 block breaking texture stays on block not being broken MC-172938 Block stuck in breaking texture if broken with torch in front. MC-173100 block "damage" saves after i stopped breaking the block MC-173306 Farmland brakes by repeatedly planting and braking crop. MC-174029 breaking block glitch MC-175935 Placing and breaking a torch on another solid block causes the latter to display breaking marks MC-180365 While breaking and placing redstone multiple times, the block underneath is broken. MC-181656 Bug with farmland MC-189919 Block keeps breaking texture when not mining the block MC-190968 Break animation on farmland MC-191795 Air cube and reed indestructible in water MC-192457 Farmland breaks when farming crops with bonemeal MC-192802 Cracked Effect Remains when placing and breaking seeds simultaniously on farmland MC-198308 Block under Crops issue MC-198754 Farmland glitch. MC-199073 Glass breaks when torches are placed on it repeatedly MC-199107 Block breaking bug MC-201788 Right then left clicking with a sappling on the dirt can leave a mark. MC-207532 Placing and breaking torch, breaks block behind MC-210077 the torch&mine bug MC-211104 Block Breaking Using Redstone MC-217258 block breaking bug MC-218419 Block breake texure broken with Sweet Barries MC-219307 breaking torchs can break grass MC-226870 Block breaking bug involving bone mealing seeds MC-227529 Torch's break blocks MC-227875 block animation pause MC-229231 placing and breaking redstone dust fast, block under the them is broken MC-229879 Rapid-fire planting and bonemealing eventually breaks the dirt block. MC-235096 Farmland seems to retain damaged state when harvesting crops MC-258727 Repeated breaking of one block flower breaks dirt blocks below MC-259071 Blocks Appear Broken When Player breaks a Block Instantly MC-259082 1.19.3 Update Bug MC-260358 farmland breaking glitch MC-263281 Breaking the new Cherry Blossom Petals on the ground. MC-263553 Breaking torch saves damage done to the block underneath MC-263821 Adjacent block breaking animation freezes MC-264357 Animation of block destruction moves to another block MC-267000 Leave break marks on block MC-267758 Torch “breaking” block behind it when torch is broken MC-271809 Breaking a insta-mineable block with a non-insta-mineable block behind keeps progress after releasing your attack button MC-273273 You Can Create Cracks On Block Or Delay The Destroy Of Block With Block That Can Be Destroyed Instantly. MC-274837 Destroying Texture doesn't dieappaer after you stop destroying! MC-279243 When breaking Wildflowers or Leaf Litters If You Continue, The Breaking Animation Will Stay MC-293623 Half Broken Blocks MC-295936 Lilly pad MC-296634 Blocks stay in breaking state when damaged with a torch on it MC-297377 There are still traces of cracks

Attachments

Comments

violine1101

Thank you for your report!
We're actually already tracking this issue in MC-69865, so I resolved and linked this ticket as a duplicate.

If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.

If you haven't already, you might like to make use of the search feature in the future to see if the issue has already been reported.

by_jove

The specific snapshot that apparently introduced this behaviour was Minecraft 1.14.4 Pre-Release 6.

violine1101

Reopened since this behaviour didn't exist prior to 1.14.4-pre6, as opposed to MC-69865.

by_jove

Some (maybe distracting) information to add:

  1. The rate at which the block breaks increases if the player is wielding the appropriate tool for the block. It's not always 1 "point" of crackage.

  2. This only works with blocks that are naturally instantly breakable with an open hand; I have not been able to recreate this using efficiency tools on dirt, shears on leaves, or by trying to hit a block through chickens.

skztr

This issue becomes very obvious when holding right-click to use bonemeal to grow crops while holding the replacement crop in off-hand. (ie: <hold right>bonemeal, <still holding right>bonemeal, <still holding right>bonemeal, <click left>break , <still holding right>place new crop, <still holding right>bonemeal... and so on). The farmland becomes damaged over time, and eventually breaks.

 

The "damage" to the farmland does not go away unless the farmland is hit exactly once, directly, without holding right-click, at which point the damage resets.

Swekob
3A 'n 2A Kids

i could reproduce this only because my mouse was broken lol

after a few days i changed my mouse

it can be reproduced in 1.12.2 & 1.15.2

Krishna Kokatay

Reproduced in 1.16.1

Krishna Kokatay

This has been partially fixed in 1.16.3. The block still goes through the breaking animation, and freezes the animation if you stop prematurely, however the actual block breaking upon completion of the break block animation (the cracks through the block), does not result in a broken block. I cannot find the bugfix that directly solved this issue.

 

Though I'm weary to call this issue completely fixed. There is still the problem of the block breaking animation occuring. And the fact that it remains until the block is interacted with again.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w03a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 21w11a.

Tiffany Lynch

Can confirm 1.17

Catherine

Can confirm 1.17.1 Pre-Release 1; I was wondering why my farmland kept breaking during bonemeal frenzies.

Tokes

Note: I reported partially broken blocks staying partially broken back in 1.8 (since 1.7.x didn't have the behaviour). It was ignored then and it's been ignored in the 7 years that have passed since then. Don't expect a quick resolution to this.

9zq

1.17 in a realm this issue happens. Made a fast farm. (Dispensers with bone meal and a redstone clock.) farmland will start displaying animation as I fast farm. farmland usually breaks but not always. If you look away from the farmland for a few seconds the breaking animation disappears. 

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.17.1.

Fabio Fraissat

I have this issue in 1.17: a sweeping edge killing chamber, where while i'm afking the dispenser that puts the minecart in for me to hit it keeps breaking time after time

shufboyardee

Can confirm in 21w44a.

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.18.1.

Avoma

Can confirm in 1.18.2.

woshikedayaa

Can confirm in 1.19

Moulberry

This is the same bug as MC-69865

The 1-line fix for this bug is outlined here: MC-255057

shufboyardee

can confirm in 1.20 Pre-release 1

windwend

Can confirm in 1.19.4

SergZabiyaka

Can confirm in 23w44a

GuiTaek

I found out, in which version exactly this bug was introduced. In version 1.14-pre5, this bug doesn't occur, in version 1.14-pre6, this bug occurs

zychen027

can confirm in 1.21

 

lootdzy

Avoma

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Platform

Low

Block states

1.14.4, 19w39a, 19w40a, 19w45b, 1.15, ..., 1.21.4, 25w02a, 25w03a, 25w08a, 1.21.5

Retrieved