mojira.dev
MC-184264

All cave sounds play at the same pitch

In the earlier versions Cave Sounds played different pitches, higher and deeper

(0.8-1) now in this New Version Cave Sounds only play pitch(1), May I know whether this is a change of MOJANG or a Bug?

Thanks to All the Moderators.

 

INSTRUCTIONS:

(create a World)

Go into a dark cave

wait until you hear the "ambient.cave" sound.

Do you also hear Pitch 1 Cave Sounds? Let me know.

 

I do not believe that cave sounds should always play at pitch(1), because of this I think this is a bug.

In Bedrock Edition the pitch range is (0.8-1) until today.

 

Attachments

Comments 15

Hello! Can you still reproduce this bug in 21w15a or 1.16.5?

@Brevort yes I can. 

Can you please update the Affected Versions? Thanks.

Out of curiosity, how do you know they are the same pitch? Do you have perfect pitch or something, or are you like recording them and playing them back? (I'm just trying to get information on how to reproduce this so I can confirm it)

@Brevort , in earlier versions like in 1.13.2 I made Minecraft Survival Livestreams on Youtube (you can watch), and as soon as I heard a cave sound, I started analyzing the pitch by creating another world where I play the cave sounds by command block in a row ( pitch: 1, 0.98, 0.96, etc until 0.82) playsound. I placed a shield and I wrote everything on it. Cave sounds were very common that time, but since 1.16 full version was released, they became rare and I realized they had the same pitch. 

I found out they were at same pitch by normally using playsound command without changing the volume or the pitch.

How I reproduced it? Example: I went mining for diamonds and all stone sorts(andesite,granite,diorite). In all of a sudden I hear a cave sound. In my situation I heard cave sound nr4.

5 more comments

This issue still persist in 1.19.4

Can confirm this issue in 1.20

Does MOJANG know about this? I believe, the gaming experience would be way better and more interesting, especially in the new deepslate caves, if the good old pitch range (0.8-1) of the playing cave noises would still persist.

Kaweh

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Sound

20w20b, 21w15a, 1.19, 1.19.1, 1.19.2, 1.19.3, 1.19.4, 23w14a, 1.20.1

Retrieved