[MC-1880] Falling particles, running particles and breaking particles use the bottom texture of that block

The bug

When breaking blocks, the particles are only from the bottom side texture of that block. This bug it's present since Beta 1.7.2. In Beta 1.7_01 that particles used the texture of the side on which the pointer was.

Also, when running and falling, the blocks use their bottom textures, when it would be more correct if they used their top side texture.

How to reproduce

Sprint on grass blocks or falling on grass blocks, the particles are from the bottom texture.

Hit a workbench on its top side, the particles will use the bottom texture (it's the oak planks texture).

Related issues

is duplicated by

MC-10122 Sprinting on/punching a bed gives of bad particles.

MC-29465 Particles when landing on grass are wrong.

MC-35620 Cactus breaking particles use texture of the bottom of the cactus block

MC-51377 Cactus Gives Off Weird Particles

MC-62476 "Landing" particle bug

relates to

MC-265393 Dispenser breaking/sprinting particles are from the front face

MC-10808 Sprinting and breaking particles of piston arms use same particles as piston eventhough there no stone on the arms

MC-2614 All kinds of chests produce wrong particles when ran on/punched

Attachments

Comments

migrated 2012-11-02T11:29:53Z

[media][media][media]

CubeTheThird 2012-11-02T14:14:45Z

Can you give a specific example? Or perhaps include a screenshot?

migrated 2013-02-08T22:24:55Z

As he said, this affects for example grass blocks. breaking grass blocks (from the top) or sprinting on them will yield dirt particles, not grass ones. Attached screenshots.

migrated 2013-05-06T17:36:48Z

Most noticeable with a piston: Place it facing upwards - stone particles. Place it facing downwards - wood particles. Sideways - mixed particles.

migrated 2014-06-01T18:14:52Z

Oh wow, so it was already the side you click on before this bug was around? I would have added that to MC-2614 as an added request for a solution, but it sounded more like a suggestion that would be harder to implement than simply re-mapping the particle texture. But apparently it can't just be remapped. 😛

migrated 2014-06-18T15:02:01Z

Confirmed for 14w25a.

migrated 2014-06-23T18:20:59Z

and 14w25b...

migrated 2014-06-25T16:11:22Z

There can only be one texture for the breaking particles, and now that texture is exposed via data files so that it can be changed via resource packs, so this is now a non-issue.

tryashtar 2016-12-28T00:00:38Z

So apparently this can be fixed with a resource pack?

How can a resource pack restore the original behavior of break particles matching the face that was being mined from Beta 1.7, and making sprint/fall particles produce particles from the top texture of the block?