mojira.dev
MC-188789

Redstone on top of block entities breaks when loading a structure

Pretty self-explanatory, basically you load any structure and if redstone dust is on top of a command block, hopper, furnace, shulker box, etc when it loads it will just break, you can see they dropped when i loaded the structure (image below) 

Linked issues

MC-276992 Structure Block doesn't leave redstone wire placed on top of crafter Resolved MC-270461 Structure blocks do not properly place redstone dust on dispensers Resolved MC-266183 Structure blocks do not save redstone when it is on top of a hopper Resolved MC-266174 redstone dust on crafter load by structure block Resolved MC-233964 Redstone and repeater not loading at the same time in certain blocks Resolved

Attachments

Comments 6

Please upload the structure file used in this example.

Done, the commands basically trigger a meteor shower using fireballs

For me 9 hours ago was like 4am so that is why i didn't respond

apparently if you load the structure again it doesn't break the redstone so it might have to do with redstone loading before the blocks

 

this affects /place and structure block LOAD button but not redstone-powered structure blocks, see

[media]

Still happens in v1.21.8, and I noticed that some other blocks do the same thing when being loaded from a Structure Block manually (not via redstone), being: powered rail, detector rail, activator rail, and also carpet (but only if 2 are touching, even if different colors), and also leaf litter.

Blocks seemingly NOT affected are comparator, repeater, sign, (regular) rail, lightning/end rod, pressure plate, button, fence/gate, door/trapdoor, string, torch (regular/soul/redstone), candle, twisting vines, daylight detector, creeper head, conduit, scaffolding, lantern (regular/soul), cobweb. That's all I felt like testing.

I think the migrated comment above from 13/Oct/20 6:17 PM has a good point, so maybe Structure Blocks need to be loaded in 2 “layers”, being solid blocks first, then ones that require supports (i.e.: something underneath). Just my opinion. It’s weird though, because having other blocks, like bricks underneath doesn’t cause the issue, only certain function blocks, like hoppers, command blocks, etc.

Bryan

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Structures

block-entity

1.16 Pre-release 4, 1.16.2 Release Candidate 1, 1.16.2, 1.16.4, 20w46a, ..., 1.20.2, 23w43b, 24w14a, 1.21.1, 24w39a

Retrieved