[MC-194763] 'War Pigs' advancement can be triggered by opening a chest with corresponding loot tables, even though the chest isn't generated in bastions.

The bug

War Pigs, as the description describes, 'Loot a chest in a Bastion Remnant', should only trigger while opening a chest in Bastion Remnant. However, using command

setblock ~ ~ ~ chest{LootTable:"minecraft:chests/bastion_treasure"}

and open the generated chest also grants the advancement, even though the chest wasn't generated upon world generation/structure generation in Bastion Remnant.

Comments 4

galaxy_2alex 2020-07-13T03:17:09Z

How would a player experience this in a regular playthrough of the game, and what exact issues does this cause? Because that is simply how the advancement is triggered at the moment, I don't really see where the bug is.

g2245820920 2020-07-13T03:28:55Z

The description of this advancement is to loot a cbest in bastions, while this can be triggered outside from the bastion.

galaxy_2alex 2020-07-13T04:07:52Z

I understand that, but how would a player encounter one of those chests in a regular playthrough without chests? And if we do not take that into account, in what way does this cause an issue exactly? At the moment, those loot chests only generate in Bastion Remnants anyway.

g2245820920 2020-07-13T04:23:08Z

Won't normally encounter in regular survival without datapacks, then this may not be an issue.