[MC-204354] Pressure plates do not break when on pistons

When a pressure plate is placed on top a sideways facing piston, it will activate the piston when pressed, but not pop off, while levers and buttons pop off upon activation, giving a 0-tick pulse. The pressure plate should do the same (or alternatively the lever and button shouldn't pop off).

Linked issues

is duplicated by 1

MC-270288 Buttons and levers fall off pistons when pistons activate Resolved

Attachments

PistonPressurePlate.mp4

Comments 4

Mateus Pereira Milbradt 2020-11-06T15:21:05Z

Did you really think this would make sense if fixed?

RobinDinVienna 2020-11-06T15:38:33Z

Yes, why not? if everything pops off, except the thing that literally even overhangs when the piston extends, that makes NO sense. Honestly, if it should make sense, the plate should be the ONLY thing popping off. But as minecraft is not an exact physics simulation, it would be more useful to make it consistence across components one way or the other.

tryashtar 2020-11-07T03:15:29Z

This is intended. A pressure plate is supported even on a single glass pane

RobinDinVienna 2020-11-07T09:30:58Z

Well, a single glass pane does not move and does not pop off other redstone compomemts. This is clearly an inconsistency. I‘d like to see the rational behind this. And if that is supposed to stay, then buttoms amd levers should clearly follow the same rule.