The Bug
Trapdoor decorations in taiga_decoration_1, taiga_butcher_shop_1, taiga_masons_house_1, taiga_temple_1 and taiga_tannery_1 do not have water inside them.
To Reproduce
Execute the following command, replacing
(structure_name)with the name of the affected structures:/setblock ~ ~ ~ structure_block{mode:"LOAD", name:"minecraft:village/taiga/houses/(structure_name)",showboundingbox:1}For example:
/setblock ~ ~ ~ structure_block{mode:"LOAD", name:"minecraft:village/taiga/houses/taiga_tannery_1",showboundingbox:1}Open the structure block GUI and click on "Load" twice.
Observe that the trapdoor decorations are missing water.
Expected Result
Trapdoors decorations in taiga villages should have water inside them.
Linked issues
Attachments
Comments
anthony cicinelli
migrated
The taiga_decoration_1 had until 19w02a. The problem is that these water troughs are empty and it traps mobs (mainly villagers). This is the last possible chance to fix it.
It sounds like a feature request, but it actually seems to be an oversight. It'd be weird if these villagers being stuck forever inside these decorations is intended.
[Mod] markderickson
I can confirm in 21w07a.
migrated
[media]
Confirmed for 1.17. Several villagers (and even cats!) spawned in these troughs and can't escape.
One even spawned inside a building, as seen in the second screenshot!
ampolive
Can confirm in 1.18 Pre-release 1.
Avoma
Can confirm in 1.19.
Avoma
Can confirm in 1.19.2.
migrated
Can confirm 1.19.4 :e
[media]
migrated
Are you sure these are even suppose to have water in them? Water is such an odd choice. I believe they were suppose to have Grass Block in them with a flower on top. The trapdoors surround the Grass Block to make it look like a small garden. It fits and looks much better than water
migrated
@unknown, bro fill them even with bedrock, I don't care, just make villagers not stuck in them so whole village dead in night one
migrated
There's actually 2 distinct issues in 1 report here:
The structures no longer have water
Mobs get stuck behind open trapdoors
I highly suggest splitting off the AI part from this report.
ampolive
@unknown The AI part is WAI (MC-50556).
migrated
I'm aware, you're missing my point. The report should be reduced to fully focus on the lack of water that used to be there, the AI is of no importance to the issue. (Remove last line from "The bug" section, and modify summary to not direct to mob AI.)
ampolive
Done.
migrated
So it will be dirt/grass/water? And will we get fix in 1.20 at least?
Water in cold biome is weird choice actually
migrated
I think it could be Grass with flowers, but the 3-block long decoration (taiga_decoration_1) would have water, as it was originally planned
Did they ever have water in them?