mojira.dev
MC-2195

Open lid of chests shows z-fighting with item frames

The opened lid of chest shows z-fighting with item frames placed on the wall behind.
Only viewable when either bug MC-515 kicks in or in SMP for other players

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media]
kumasasa

Screenshot in better resolution

kumasasa

And even better resolution

Konstantin Grobmogilka

Related to MC-378. Other transparent block such as signs, however, don't cause z-fighting, but go through chest cover.

kumasasa

No, it's not a matter of going through, it's just the texture fighting what is really annoying because flickering

Richard Cox

Duplicate of MC-1759

kumasasa

No again, it's not a duplicate. It's no problem that either the lid of the chest is going through the item frame or vice versa, it's the flickering texture fighting what's really annoying (both textures are in the same plane)

Richard Cox

@Kumasasa Am I correct in understanding that – if the flickering was removed by having the item frame in front of the chest lid – you would not consider the placement of item frame in front of the chest lid a bug?

IOW you are proposing that an opening chest lid passing behind any item frames places on a block one block above and behind the chest.

I consider any flickering as an irrelevant consequence of the underlying bug: the chest lid is not in front of the item frame.

kumasasa

There are some differnet things to consider:

  • I aree with you that the item frame should be behind the lid of the chest, the texture fighting will then be gone (A)

  • A block in a frame is going through the lid (B) (OK for me)

  • An item in a frame is behind behind the lid (C) (also OK for me)

  • A sign is goind through the lid (D) (also OK for me)

To forbid opening chests with item frames or signs in the block above is a no-go, because frames and signs are useless then.

Tom Mate

still in 1.4.7

kumasasa

Duplicate of MC-2195 (finally duped this ticket, Richard Cox, you're right...)

kumasasa

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

chest, item-frame, texture, z-fighting

Minecraft 1.4.3, Minecraft 1.4.5, Minecraft 1.4.7, Snapshot 13w05a, Snapshot 13w07a

Retrieved