[MC-236645] Illagers can't win raids if baby villagers are present

Tested in creative with a bunch of adult and baby villagers and started a raid.

The illagers killed off all the adult villagers but the raid was still ongoing without a Defeat status.

Expected Result

The raid would end in a defeat when all adult villagers are killed

Attachments

Comments 23

Sniper1.1 2021-09-16T08:05:58Z

Called it! When I read that change I somehow thought “I bet they forgot to change raid defeat conditions to not count children.”

Dmitry Konev 2021-09-16T14:55:11Z

Can confirm that this is an issue.

Pelle Reinke 2021-09-16T23:32:35Z

@Anthony Cicinelli I see you have edited the title of the report, it is a bit misleading since Illagers can win a raid, just not when there are baby villagers present in the village.

charlygulati 2021-11-03T20:10:57Z

Can confirm in 21w43a

charlygulati 2021-11-03T21:08:20Z

Can confirm in 21w44a

13 more comments

Orbic 2021-11-11T19:16:43Z

Can confirm for 1.18 Pre-1. Ravagers still kill baby villagers, but if a raid wave spawns without a Ravager they simply cannot win and everyone just sorta runs around.

[media]

Sniper1.1 2021-11-11T19:39:49Z

Surprised to see it’s not fixed. I don’t know the code, but I doubt this’d be a major pain to fix.

charlygulati 2021-11-24T16:12:26Z

This seems to be fixed in 1.18 Pre Release 8.

[media][media]

If I had to guess, this is probably as a result of fixing of MC-236783

Tokes 2021-11-25T03:34:16Z

Btw over a long enough time period those baby villagers would grow up and then be targetable by the raiders.

Sniper1.1 2021-11-25T12:50:02Z

Imagine raiding a village and killing everyone except the children, then waiting years for the children to grow up, and then killing them lol.

Sniper1.1 2021-11-26T22:00:19Z

From my research this is still not fixed. I went to a village, ensured there were kids, and started a raid. I helped kill all adults (I gave everyone glowing so I could find them). When it was just kids and raiders left, the raid was still going. I /kill-ed the remaining childcare and then the raid ended with the raiders celebrating.

This was release candidate 3

charlygulati 2021-11-29T18:31:13Z

I have had a weird discovery. I was testing this by creating a new village (by spawning Villager through spawn eggs) and that is when the raid comes to a defeat when the adult villagers die but in naturally generated villager, the raid still continues even when all adult villagers die.

So, can confirm for Release Candidate 4, at least in the case of naturally generated villages.

Irfon Hughes Calvin 2021-11-29T23:46:34Z

I believe this issue is on purpose to make Raids slightly easier, but you must still defeat the Raid within 20 minutes. It could be meant to make Raiders more humane.