[MC-248183] minecraft:cave_vine and minecraft:cave_vine_in_moss from /place always claim to succeed, even when they don't

The Bug

When using the /place feature command to place the minecraft:cave_vine feature, it fails to load if air is not present below the target location, but still shows up as successful.

Features Affected

minecraft:cave_vine

Reproduce

Do /place feature minecraft:cave_vine ~ ~ ~

Observed Result

The game said it was loaded but nothing appeared.

Expected Result

The feature would be properly placed or the error message "Failed to place feature" would come up.

Linked issues

relates to 1

MC-248220 minecraft:fossil_coal and minecraft:fossil_diamond features from /place claim to succeed but don't work client-side Open

Attachments

MC-248183.mp4

MC-248183 - Behavior when air isn't present below desired placing location.png

MC-248183 - Behavior when air is present below desired placing location.png

Comments 4

Hound4oo4 2022-01-29T12:11:13Z

Why does the image say fossil coal when the report is on glowburries?

ampolive 2022-04-11T12:34:27Z

Originally this was about all the features, until it was split into separate reports.

Avoma 2022-04-11T12:35:48Z

I can confirm this in 22w14a, although, it's important to note and probably worth clarifying that this issue can only be reproduced whilst air is not present below the desired placing location. If it is, the feature would be successfully placed.

[media][media][media]

Avoma 2022-07-06T10:38:52Z

Can confirm in 1.19.