mojira.dev
MC-262179

Unconnected tripwire's shape is inconsistent with other unconnected blocks

The bug

If a single unit of tripwire is placed down and is not connected to any adjacent blocks, it will appear as an orthogonal line. This is inconsistent with other blocks with similar such connection behaviour: they either appear as a single centered unit (iron bars, glass panes, fences, walls, redstone wire after toggling) or connected in all directions (redstone wire by default).

How to reproduce

  1. Create a floor out of dark blocks

  2. Place down a single piece of string

Expected results

The placed string would either appear as a single centered dot (for consistency with most orthogonally connecting blocks) or a cross (for visibility and for consistency with redstone dust).

Actual results

It appears as an orthogonal line instead.

How to fix

This is completely down to the blockstates file for tripwire. This issue can be fixed entirely by editing that alone. I can provide an example resource pack if desired.

Attachments

Comments 4

Confirmed, but as pointed out the dot design is not favorable for tripwire; it's already hard to see.

This report is selective in its appeal to examples: rails connect but do not appear as a dot or cross when placed by themselves.

Rails are different, since their connection types aren't a binary yes/no per horizontal direction: you can't have T-shaped rails, for example.

I've asked internally about this and the response was that this report looks like a suggestion / feature request. An inconsistency is not necessarily a bug. Changing resolution to Invalid.

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Textures and models

1.19.4, 23w17a

Retrieved