mojira.dev
MC-271902

Breaking a Shulker Box with your hand destroys the Shulker Box with all of it's items inside

Breaking a Shulker Box with your hand destroys the Shulker Box with all of it's items inside.  [Rare, apparently]

 

Reproduce:
1 - Fill items in a Shulker box placed on the ground.

2 - Under Survival Mode, break it without a tool using only the Player's hand.

Expected behavior:

Drops the shulker box as an item, still preserving all of your items that were stored inside, like the previous behavior.

Attachments

Comments 8

I cannot reproduce, it does drop the shulker box only.

[media]

Perhaps it's with a previous snapshot shulker box?  Let me check from 1.20.4 and 1.20.6

 

Strange and now I can't reproduce it.  I do not understand why, because it did happen, and I'm not going crazy though, and no, the box was NOT on the ground.

Did you have the gamerule doTileDrops set to false?

Nope, I went back to the same world and tried to reproduce and could not.

Also for context, I can't prove it, but I had another person say they had the same problem recently.

Was this world upgraded from any previous version?

The world where I had the problem, was a world where I was testing a MOD that I was working on, and has existed through most of the 1.20.5 snapshot cycle (Since at least like 24w04a or 10a), and it was being tested upon under 1.20.6 prior to this happening.
Also, I was not able to reproduce the issue in the same world with another shulker box.

The Shulker Box in question may have existed under the RC releases, or 1.20.5 prior, and it was different, because it was placed on the ground in between a few upgrades.

... Speaking of which, I should "probably" try to trace that exact procedure, and take F3+I on the block under 1.20.5-pre and 1.20.5-rc, and after under 1.20.6, before hitting 24w19b with it, and storing a copy in a chest for a "control" object.

The other player didn't offer specifics, but they said that they lost a shulker of Diamonds in their Survival world.

sakura-ryoko

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

block-break, block-entity, inventory

24w19b

Retrieved