mojira.dev
MC-274495

Old item translation strings for music disc descriptions go unused, confusing resource pack artists

The strings previously used for music disc descriptions before they became data-generated go unused, and had not been removed when the translations were changed to use a block translation instead.

Take for instance, "11":

[media]

[media]

Making the following translations empty has no affect on music disc item descriptions, only the name. This also does not affect the tool-tip shown when playing a song in a jukebox.

{
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_5": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_5.desc": "Samuel Γ…berg - 5",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_11": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_11.desc": "C418 - 11",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_13": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_13.desc": "C418 - 13",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_blocks": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_blocks.desc": "C418 - blocks",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_cat": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_cat.desc": "C418 - cat",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_chirp": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_chirp.desc": "C418 - chirp",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_creator": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_creator_music_box": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_creator_music_box.desc": "Lena Raine - Creator (Music Box)",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_creator.desc": "Lena Raine - Creator",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_far": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_far.desc": "C418 - far",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_mall": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_mall.desc": "C418 - mall",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_mellohi": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_mellohi.desc": "C418 - mellohi",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_otherside": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_otherside.desc": "Lena Raine - otherside",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_pigstep": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_pigstep.desc": "Lena Raine - Pigstep",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_precipice": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_precipice.desc": "Aaron Cherof - Precipice",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_relic": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_relic.desc": "Aaron Cherof - Relic",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_stal": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_stal.desc": "C418 - stal",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_strad": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_strad.desc": "C418 - strad",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_wait": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_wait.desc": "C418 - wait",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_ward": "Music Disc",
  "item.minecraft.music_disc_ward.desc": "C418 - ward",
}
[media]

Steps to Reproduce:

Apply the following resource pack, and hover of a disc item:

[media]

Notes:

This has caused confusion in numerous reports recently. See: MC-274494 MC-272378

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 2

I can confirm this, but based on MC-262552 and MC-265169, it most likely works as intended.

Thank you for your report!
After consideration, the issue is being closed as Working as Intended.

Please note, that mechanics of the game may change between updates.
Things such as graphics, sounds, world creation, biomes, redstone, villagers, and animals may not work the same in current versions.

Full Version History – Snapshot Version History – The official Minecraft feedback site

Quick Links:
πŸ““ Bug Tracker Guidelines – πŸ’¬ Community Support – πŸ“§ Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – πŸ“§ Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
πŸ““ Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – πŸ“– Game Wiki

[Mod] Jingy

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Text

disc, music_disc, translation

1.21

Retrieved