Steps to Reproduce:
Run command: /setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:resin_brick_wall[up=false]
Put a dirt path below the invisible resin brick wall
Run command: /setblock ~ ~ ~ minecraft:stone_brick_wall[up=false] (Note: Run this command at least 2 blocks away from resin brick wall, or its block states will update)
Put a dirt path below the invisible stone brick wall
Observed Results: After step 2, dirt path is still dirt path. In comparison, after step 4, dirt path turns into dirt. Therefore, it proves that resin brick wall without a center post is not a solid block.
Expected Results: Resin brick wall should be a solid block with whatever block states, like any other walls.
Additional information: Bedrock Edition is without this bug.
Attachments
Comments 4
false:
[east=none,north=none,south=none,up=false,waterlogged=false,west=none]
[east=none,north=none,south=none,up=false,waterlogged=true,west=none]
Hi!
Could you please record and upload a video showcasing the issue?
Please show it as you mentioned in repro steps.
This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.
I can also confirm this issue using code analysis. Other walls construct their block settings by copying the settings of their base block then marking the wall as force-solid. Resin brick walls manually repeat the block settings and do not mark themselves as force-solid.
The only block state affected is one that must be manually placed with commands which causes various effects from blocks that check for solidity, such as dirt paths, banners, signs, item frames, and more.
Another way to test this issue is to use cactus. Place a resin brick wall without any neighboring blocks, use a debug stick to make its up property false, then place a cactus to the side of it. If done correctly, the cactus will place because it is not neighboring a solid block, the resin brick wall will update its state to consider its new neighbor, and the cactus will break because it is now next to a solid block.
Can confirm.