mojira.dev
MC-2961

Some villages are generating wrong for no reason

i expected to find a normal village, but i found this one (seed and location in the photo)
i also noticed there are lots of lightning bugs

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
migrated

The misplaced torches got their own bug, see MC-2512. The rest is just how the world generator works. Jeb explained this once. This can happen depending on how the chunks are created. An adjacent chunk may not know he is intended to create parts of a house. Edit: I don't think this should be treated as a bug, it should be closed. Sorry.

migrated

What? 'Not a bug'? If only half a house generates when a whole house is supposed to generate, then that's a bug! There may be unavoidable technical reasons for why that happens, but that's beside the point. If this is to be closed, at least close it as 'won't fix', and put terrain/village generator improvements as a future feature request/refinement.

migrated

This is the first time I see part of houses erased by chunks, I believe this is a bug. I also never saw any other structures cut by chunks. Definitely not something "normal"

migrated

I'm just saying what I know. I may be wrong.

I tried to reproduce this in both 1.4.2 and 1.4.4 with the given seed and position. But the village is not damaged. See my screenshot above. The only problem are the floating torches in 1.4.4 but as said this is bug MC-2512.

migrated

i tried to regenerate it and i found it normal

migrated

Would not let me do it as a screenshot, so here is the file...

migrated

I have recreated this on three different seeds now using a vanilla install with this new snapshot and have never encountered this before - ever...

Snapshot = 13w01b
Seed = 8542012492896568057

Attached screenshot will give location.

migrated

I see similar issues. These include invisible cacti, and it seems, invisible village blocks. Note in the screengrab how some of the doors seem to be floating in midair? That's a new variation I've never seen before.

migrated

I also am unable to upload screenshots, except as attachments. I get redirected to oracle.com whenever I clcik the Attach screenshot button. Where do I report that?

migrated

It is an issue with biomes creating striped biomes. See Issue 5737: https://mojang.atlassian.net/browse/MC-5737

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 1.4.4, Minecraft 1.4.5, Snapshot 13w01a

Retrieved