mojira.dev
MC-30767

Conflicting enchantments on books

One enchanted book with enchantments for sword and boots: Smite IV, Projectile Protection IV, Fether Falling IV. Got it in survival via fishing - I don't know if that should happen...

Linked issues

MC-235407 Enchanted book glitch!!! Resolved MC-31544 enchantment book bug while fishing Resolved MC-31743 Conflicting enchantments on books Resolved MC-32915 Enchanting Books might give two incompatible enchantments Resolved MC-33185 Enchanted Books have random combo enchantments Resolved

Attachments

Comments 6

Put it on either sword or armour and pick which enchantment you want 🙂

I keep getting Power IV + an armor enchant IV. This makes these books useless since only one enchant will help but the other needlessly increases the repair cost of the item. Please fix.

How do you pick which enchantment you want? If you put 3 enchantments on one item, you cannot repair that item easily. Since all of these are higher ranked enchantments, it is not feasible to repair the item. After the item wears down, you would just toss it. I'm sorry, but this seems to be either very dumb, or very flawed. Why not just put one higher ranked enchantment on a book, or make a book where you can choose an enchantment that it will have?

Or a way to strip an unwanted enchantment would work too.

Dinnerbone was kind enough to go out of his way and clarify the issue for me:

"If you have a book with 3 different types of enchants on an item, only valid ones will go through and you don't pay penalties."

Thanks Dinnerbone, and hope this helps any others who did not understand this.

Also they've talked about adding the ability to remove enchantments soon. Next major version (1.8) or the one after (1.9).

Dilgo Elias Lienhard

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

book, enchanted, fishing

Minecraft 13w36b

Retrieved