mojira.dev
MC-48459

Unrealistic Crafting Recipes - Trapdoors give too less as compared to doors

Trapdoors give too less as compared to doors, this is a really unrealistic crafting comparing earlier versions (1.7.4 and lower)
Explaination:
In 1.7.4 and below:
6 wood/iron = 2 doorblocks = 1 door or 2 trapdoors
In the 1.8 snapshots:
6 wood/iron = 6 doorblocks = 3 doors
6 wood = 2 doorblocks = 2 trapdoors
4 iron = 1 doorblock = 1 trapdoor
Do you see what is wrong? If not then this is what is wrong:
A wooden or iron door cost first 6 planks or iron and gave 1 door(=2 doorblocks) or 2 trapdoors(=2 doorblocks aswell)
Now a wooden or iron door cost 6 planks or iron and gives 3 doors(=6 doorblocks) or 2 trapdoors(=2 doorblocks)
A good fix for this would be:
Crafting: 6 wood/iron = 3 doors(=6 doorblocks) or 6 trapdoors(=6 doorblocks aswell). Please remember with this: iron trapdoors cost 4 iron so it would give 4 trapdoors(=4 doorblocks)

It is a quite unfair contradistinction. I explain it aswell with pictures.

Note: Because this can look like a new feature instaid of a bug, it is really a bug. It reminds me of: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-29510 . It is a same kind of bug.

Attachments

Comments 4

This site is for bug reports only. For feature suggestions or changes please see: Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.

As I said it is not a suggestion, but a bug.
Please read my explaination:
"Note: Because this can look like a new feature instaid of a bug, it is really a bug. It reminds me of: https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-29510 . It is a same kind of bug."

...the bug you mentioned was probably planned to be fixed with completely new trees. That's no argument.
There are alot of recipies that could be "unrealistic" in someone's point of view. Remember, the slogan of Minecraft is not "Realism". This is no bug, it's a feature request, expect you can find a similar report asbout something else here.

i think this is a bug too. perhaps they didnt think to change this when they made the door crafting recipe give 3 doors. and in 1.7 it made sense so i assume they'd want to keep it that way

karstvgl

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 14w05b, Minecraft 14w06b, Minecraft 14w07a

Retrieved