mojira.dev
MC-5686

Entity's cooldown timer is reset when the entity touches a nether portal

The portal cooldown timer on the minecart ruins the fun in general.
But that could be happening on some unclear purpose.

But I assume it's resetting every time the cart touches a portal.
Which sounds more like a bug.

Therefore my bruteforce attept on teleporting a cart also doesn't work
(Attached picture)
I would expect the cart to teleport as the 30s cooldown timer runs out, but it never actually teleports.

Related issues

MC-6353 Error in entities (Minecarts) traveling through two portals MC-9279 Minecarts through portal bug MC-11721 Cows can only make 1-way trips through nether portals MC-11862 Sending a friendly NPC through a Nether Portal MC-12557 Entities that travelled through a Nether portal can not travel through a Nether portal again MC-15001 Horse nether bug MC-15486 Horses MC-15710 Certain Villagers won't travel through portal from the nether. MC-16315 Animals trapped in the Nether MC-16702 mule wont come back from nether MC-16774 A Horse Once In The Nether Can Not Go Through A Nether Portal. MC-16934 Horse can travel through Nether-Portal only single time MC-18349 tamed horses can not go through a nether portal in the nether to the real world MC-20182 Horses can't leave the Nether :( MC-22559 horses cant travel back from the nether MC-23199 (SMP) Saddled Mules (with chest) unable to go through nether portals MC-23249 Horses and nether portals not working properly MC-26170 Horses not always going through Nether Portals MC-26794 horses MC-27718 Horse can go through Nether Portal to the Nether, but can't go back to Overworld. MC-30979 Horses and portals MC-32961 Horses cant not get out of the nether. MC-39205 Minecart cant use a nether portal after exiting one without breaking it. MC-168871 horse stuck in neither MC-173503 My minecraft dog wont go back through my netherportal. MC-272877 The leaded boat throw the nether portal,Sometimes Although you lead the boat out of the nether portal and go in to it again,the boat can't teleport to other dimension

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media]
migrated

Confirmed in 13w05b.

migrated

What about preventing the mob/cart from using the SAME portal during the cooldown period,
but allowing the cart/mob to use any other portal?

(rephrase: Tying cooldown to the last/particular portal the mob/cart arrived from)

That shall be both easy to implement and increase the fun.

migrated

can a mod update the affected versions for this post?

migrated

Had an odd variation on this happen to me: A pair of sheep who had been in the nether for a while and were not touching the portal when I came through would not go back through when I tried to push them. So does the cooldown apply to all mobs regardless of whether it is a mob or player who touches the portal?

migrated

Unless there are players in the nether, it gets unloaded and thus frozen in time.

migrated

/me is sad about this cargo-railway-build-preventing code hackery being intended.
+ I still don't see a reason for resetting the timer when the entity isn't teleported.

migrated

Reason: MC-54

migrated

Can't other mobs be teleported a bit further from the portal as to prevent this timer cooldown thing, or at least make the cooldown a little lower like 5-10 seconds? It frustrating like this. Please! This is what is bothering us!

migrated

Seconded.

Or perhaps bind the timer to a specific portal.

migrated

For feature suggestions or changes please use the Minecraft Forums: Suggestions.

migrated

It's not a new feature, it's a bug, the cooldown is to long and causes problems that where not intended to happen. Something must be changed! I and other commenters gave some suggestions about how it should actually work. Don't skew the meaning, please, it's a bug, not a feature.

migrated

Dear Tails,
Thanks for taking interest in this old Bug.

My Bug is only about minecart and about entities WITHOUT AI.
When it leaves the portal, it must be free to enter another.
There is no need for this timer.
If you implement that, then I just can put my Mobs into minecarts and problem solved.

Here, I have you another way to fix this!
I beg you to reconsider.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

entity, nether_portal

Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.4.7, Snapshot 13w01b, Snapshot 13w05b, Minecraft 1.5, Snapshot 13w11a, Minecraft 1.5.1, Minecraft 1.5.2, Snapshot 13w18c, Snapshot 13w19a

Retrieved