mojira.dev
MC-64066

Blocking and mining

Put the summary of the bug you're having here When you block with a sword and you mine if you let go of the mining button and not the blocking you don't loose the progress until you let go of the blocking

What I expected to happen was...: To lose the progress when letting go of the mining button
Describe what you thought should happen here I would loose the mining process

*What actually happened was...:*When you block with a sword and you mine if you let go of the mining button and not the blocking you don't loose the progress until you let go of the blocking
Describe what happened here

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Put a step by step guide on how to trigger the bug here
2. ...Block with a sword and mine a block
3. ... keep blocking and let go of the mining

Linked issues

MC-65177 Breaking blocks/hitting with sword Resolved MC-65271 When you shield yourself and try to break a block the breaking animation stays as it is for a certain amount of time. doesn't work the first time but try again and it does Resolved MC-65282 Blocking/Mining Bug Resolved MC-65800 Blocks stay broken while hitting them and blocking with a sword in Survival Resolved MC-66593 Digging Animation and Progress stands still Resolved

Attachments

Comments 11

Confirmed for 14w30c. Also added screenshots. It also continues even if you move what block you're facing

[Mod] redstonehelper

Confirmed for 1.8-pre1.

[Mod] redstonehelper

Only semi-fixed in 1.8-pre2: You can still block while mining a block, which pauses the block breaking animation and will keep it around until the right mouse button is released, even when you walk away. Please re-open.

Mog (Ryan Holtz)

You are straight-up awesome at finding interesting bugs!

What do you feel would be a good fix for this issue? As it's no longer possible to begin breaking a block while blocking with a sword, I think it should also not be possible to begin blocking while breaking a block. Your thoughts?

[Mod] redstonehelper

That's probably the best (and easiest) way to fix this, it would be consistent with the prior fix too.

1 more comments

The same happens when you are mining and a mob (I used a jumping horse) stand betwheen you and the block and you hit him, the breaking texture will still be there even though you stopped mining.

I think this is probably fixed now per MC-70359.

I cannot confirm this happens in 1.8 by blocking or eating, why was it actually reopened

Confirmed in 1.8 by first mining, then blocking/eating.

[Mod] redstonehelper

Probably best to resolve this as a duplicate of MC-70359 since that one covers more and has been marked as fixed already.

SAZ Zarrabi

migrated

Confirmed

Minecraft 14w30c, Minecraft 14w31a, Minecraft 14w32b, Minecraft 14w32c, Minecraft 14w32d, Minecraft 1.8-pre1

Minecraft 1.8-pre2

Retrieved