mojira.dev
MC-80829

Dead player keeps chunks loaded

Relates to:

Based on MC-64261 I assume that there is some code which should prevent players, who died from seeing what's going on after their death.

When you die, you keep the chunks loaded.

How to reproduce:

  1. /setworldspawn

  2. /tp ~10000 ~ ~ (in a area which isn't loaded by default)

  3. Place a simple redstone clock with a command block containing a command, for example: /say Loaded

  4. /kill

You will see that the command block continues printing "Loaded" until you press "Respawn".

In general there is no reason why a dead player should be able to see what is going on after their death, so you could even consider this as an exploit. A solution would be to stop sending a dead player any player, entity or chunk updates until he respawns.

If someone wants a dead player to be able to spectate, they should use the spectator mode I guess.

Linked issues

Comments 8

Anon Ymus

Confirmed.

Samuel Klumpers

I think this is more of a feature suggestion or opinion than an issue, is it?

marcono1234

I am not sure, I don't see any use why a dead player should load chunks...

Erik Broes

Until respawn, he's still there and can look around.

marcono1234

Are you sure that is intended? Because I cannot move at all when I am dead and if somebody would actually like to have this they would put the dead player in spectator mode

Bren Rado

This also means that mobs don't despawn, right?

Bren Rado

@Marcono1234: In a server, since you can't move, you'd be kicked for AFK if this happened for a while, because the chunk is still loaded, and I agree that the dead player should be put into spectator mode as to prevent involuntary AFK players.

erikrrn

i died in the nether and went back to get my netherite gear floating on the lava but it wasn't there. this explains why. 😞

marcono1234

Erik Broes

Confirmed

chunk, chunk-updates, dead, death, death-screen

Minecraft 1.8.6

Retrieved