mojira.dev
MC-9436

Blocks that must be supported by other blocks, such as torches, doors, and levers, have strange behavior on certain blocks

I can almost guarantee that this contains some duplicates, however, I would rather post all instances I found in one place than try and weed out the specific instances that have been reported already.

---------------

Blocks affected: Glass, Redstone Block, Glowstone, Slab, Stair

Blocks used for testing: Repeater, Door, Pressure Plate, Button, Lever (top, bottom, side), Rail, Ladder, Trapdoor, Torch (top, side), Flowerpot, Redstone Dust, Fire (top, bottom, side)

----------------

First image: Control. How we would expect blocks that must be attatched to other blocks to behave.

Glass: Non-solid block. Would expect it to support nothing, yet supports torches, just on top.

Redstone Block: Does not support Buttons or Ladders.

Glowstone: Supports only Redstone Dust and Trapdoor

Slab and Stair: Special case. Only thing I expected to work that did not is a lever on the bottom of a bottom slab/stair.

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media][media][media][media][media][media]
migrated

Most of this works as intended.

migrated

So you aren't going to note the ones that don't work as intended?

migrated

What's not intended has already been submitted.

migrated
  • Glass and torches: intended

  • Redstone Block: see MC-5850

  • Glowstone: intended

  • Slab/Stair: intended

migrated

You aren't supposed to be able to put levers on the bottoms of slabs when you can put them on the top? What's the reasoning behind that?

migrated

I suppose you can create a separate ticket for that case.

migrated

You should be able to put levers on the bottom of lower slabs and the top of upper slabs, but the other way around would result in the lever being half in one block and half in another, and that's something the game can't handle by its design.

migrated

Not quite. There was a mod a while back that allowed you too place torches on bottom slabs, by just lowering the mesh and bounding box by half a block. The torch itself was still technically in the block above the slab.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

button, door, fire, flower_pot, glass, glowstone, ladder, lever, pressure_plate, rail, redstone, redstone-repeater, slab, stair, torch, track, trapdoor

Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.4.7, Snapshot 13w05b, Snapshot 13w06a

Retrieved