mojira.dev
MC-5850

Buttons, levers, ladders and tripwire hooks can't be placed on sides and bottom of redstone blocks

You can place levers on top of redstone blocks, but not on the sides.
You can't place tripwire hooks, ladders or buttons on the sides of redstone blocks.

Edit: added ladders to the list, updated version (it's still present in 13w09c).

Related issues

MC-11716 Lever on redstone block MC-16553 Ladder Redstoneblock Bug MC-26024 Levers cannot be placed on the sides of Redstone Blocks, but can be put on the top MC-60171 Levers can't be placed on redstone blocks MC-62675 When placing levers on redstone blocks they break if updated MC-69747 When placing lever on redstone block it breaks MC-71519 Lever placed on a Redstone-Block disappears after activating MC-71550 Can't place lever on a redstoneblock MC-91502 Redstone Blocks are Bugging with Buttons MC-106090 i cant put stone button in redstone block MC-112061 You can not put the lever on the side faces of the block red_stone can put only lever up and down MC-112520 Can't Place Ladders on Observer Blocks MC-112685 Lever can not put all the girls side of the Bloc Reston ! MC-203822 Amethyst Piston Glitch

Comments

migrated

I see no beneficial reason to attach those items to a block that's always powered.

migrated

Yes, makes no sense to do that.

migrated

Buttons, levers and tripwire hooks power all the blocks they are touching, not only the one they are attached to.

migrated

I don't understand what you are trying to say, they allways touch 1 block

migrated

Levers, tripwire hooks and buttons power the block they are attached to/touching, but they also power redstone, pistons, lamps, doors,tnt and other blocks below and to the sides... Like this: (R=redstone block, L=lever, .=redstone dust powered by the lever but not the redstone block)
Sideways:

RL.
.

Front:

.L.
.

You could use it to make some circuits smaller.

migrated

Ladders also cannot be attached (while they do attach to iron or lapis lazuli blocks) while torches and vines do can.
Speaking of vines, its downgrowth can be blocked with buttons etc - a nice decorative feature IMO.

migrated

Ladders, buttons, levers and hooks still cannot be attached to redstone blocks in 13w06a.

migrated

Confirmed.

migrated

Still needs to be fixed as of 13w09b.

migrated

Still in 13w23b

migrated

Confirmed for 1.6.1.

Also, this can conceivably be an issue with tripwire hooks (which power at both ends, one of which may not have a redstone block), and even moreso when building decorative structures from redstone blocks and wanting to have ladders (which have no role in redstone whatsoever).

Ezekiel

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

migrated

Confirmed for 1.6.2.

migrated

Confirmed for 1.7.5 and 14w08a

migrated

Confirmed for 14w11b

migrated

Confirmed for 1.7.9 and 14w17a

marcono1234

I guess it's some kind of intended.
Because the redstone block is nearly handled like a glowstone block
(Chests can be opened when redstone block above (14w20b))
and you can place buttons on glowstone so...

migrated

Confirmed for 1.8

migrated

Shouldn't they be either be placable on all faces or none, it's common sense

migrated

I see no reason why these blocks can't be placed on redstone blocks. Many other blocks, such as redstone wire, torches, and rails all work fine. Please reopen.

migrated

@@unknown: If Mojang says something is WAI it is WAI.

FaRo1

Confirmed for 16w15b (at least for ladders). It can't be working as intended, all other ore blocks work and redstone blocks aren't transparent (as you can easily check, it doesn't let light through).

migrated

Read 1 comment before yours, @unknown resolved this as intended, if mojang says it's intended, it's intended.

clamlol

This issue is no longer present, and I suspect it was "fixed" in 1.14 when the faces of full/solid transparent blocks were allowed to support other blocks.

migrated

michael

Confirmed

Snapshot 13w01a, Snapshot 13w06a, Snapshot 13w09c, Minecraft 1.5, Snapshot 13w11a, ..., Minecraft 14w11b, Minecraft 1.7.9, Minecraft 14w17a, Minecraft 14w29b, Minecraft 1.8.8

Retrieved