minecraft launcher uses old directory even when a new one has been given

... Why reopened?

I created a new 1.5.2 Version with Forge in it, and then created a new profile to use this version an the folder of a working FTB pack.
The game started correctly but there were no mods and the texturepack and saves folder were obviously in the old MC directory, so from my point of view, this post has to be open.

Daniel, pre1.6 doesn't observe directory settings.

Oops I was wrong

Ezekiel, it does. I've tried it with 1.5.2 and 1.5.1. It will download and install to a new directory if it's a new version, but if you try to change the directory again it doesn't acknowledge said change. This becomes a problem with local only versions because they're never installed to begin with.

Edit: Nevermind. It works for any version that exists on the new launcher. Local or kept up to date on remote. So any 1.6, 1.5, or snapshot shown on the launcher will be able to change their game directory where they see fit. The version I need working is 1.4.5 which isn't listed.

Tl;dr: The problem isn't with pre-1.6 jars. It's with jars not on hosted on the dev launcher. (1.4 and under)

Blaze, I later noticed this. Any versions not up to date with remote don't seem to be able to switch folders.

Ezekiel, that's not entirely true either. =P As long as there is a version on the launcher it'll work regardless of being local or being kept up to date with remote.

For instance. If I make a copy of 1.5.1 and rename it to something else, it's no longer "up to date with remote" but rather it's only "local". However. Because the launcher has a 1.5.1.jar on it it'll work. A 1.4.5.jar or lower won't work though.

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft / Launcher version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

I think it's fixed

Thanks.

It's not fixed. In the image I just attached you can see I'm running my .jar with the custom directory but nothing is in there but the server.log file. I'm on launcher 1.1.1.

@BlazeFaia:
Minecraft 1.4.7 ? Forge ? Optifine ? MCP ?

Recreate with vanilla 1.6.2.

But the title of this bug report doesn't specifically state 1.6.2. Just that new directories don't work. So even though it works for 1.6.2-1.5.1 anything lower doesn't work. That's still a bug that needs to be fixed.

Also whoops, meant to say 1.4.7. Not 1.4.5.

Works with vanilla 1.5.2

I said it worked with 1.6.2-1.5.1 XP What it wasn't working with was 1.4.7. Well. It WASN'T working. I tried a fresh vanilla 1.4.7 and it worked. Tried to install Forge and I got the same problem. So Forge is the problem here. Looks like this problem is indeed fixed.

@BlazeFaia:

• Check if you see the --gameDir argument in the "Running" line

• Check if you see Client> Setting gameDir to:d:\minecraft\test

  Launching in d:\minecraft\test
  Running C:\Program Files\Java\jre7\bin\javaw.exe -Xmx1G ...  --gameDir d:\minecraft\test 
  Client> Jul 20, 2013 9:22:12 PM net.minecraft.launchwrapper.LogWrapper log
  Client> INFO: Using tweak class name net.minecraft.launchwrapper.VanillaTweaker
  Client> Jul 20, 2013 9:22:13 PM net.minecraft.launchwrapper.LogWrapper log
  Client> INFO: Launching wrapped minecraft
  Client> Turning of ImageIO disk-caching
  Client> Loading current icons for window from: ....
  Client> Setting gameDir to:d:\minecraft\test

  If one of the two things is missing, it won't work.