mojira.dev
MCPE-166303

Inconsistent dyes with firework stars

The recipe book reads that firework stars (small ball single color) are made with a dye and gunpowder, but when you check it, a couple of them aren't consistent. This is what happens when you try and make black or white firework stars:

Expected result: Put in gunpowder and black or white dye and get a firework star!

Bug: Put in gunpowder and either an ink sac or bone meal and get a firework star...

I wouldn't have reported this if cacao beans were part of it too (it would make it seem more intentional) but they aren't, a brown firework star uses brown dye like you'd expect.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 1

Re-testing in 1.20.51, I find that bone meal, ink sac, cocoa beans, and lapis lazuli are all accepted as dyes for making a firework star, so this behavior has now become consistent. I don't think this is the intended behavior, because Java Edition doesn't allow these items to be used as dyes, but we are tracking the parity disagreement as MCPE-42473 so this ticket could be resolved. However, Mojang has not yet closed it internally, so we'll have to keep this ticket open until they do.

BandanaHawk

(Unassigned)

382714

Confirmed

Multiple

Windows 10

1.19.51, 1.20.51 Hotfix, 1.21.44 Hotfix

Retrieved