mojira.dev
MCPE-169313

Freshly generated chunks cause boats and chestboats to disappear when riding in them

When riding in a boat on ice in a chunk that has not yet been visited, the boat or chestboat will suddenly disappear.

If the boat is a chestboat, any items stored in the chestboat will also disappear. Exiting and reloading the world can usually allow the boat to reappear and if this works the chest boat and its items can be recovered.

This bug is similar to MCPE-169022, however I have not seen that issue arise since the release of 1.19.80.23. So, a boat disappearing on water appears to be fixed but still occurs if one is used on ice.

Steps to Reproduce:

  • Turn off all custom global resources to ensure nothing else is affecting the game.

  • Ensure the render distance is set to the recommended level (in my case 40).

  • Create a new Creative Mode world using a random seed, and optionally turn on coordinates.

  • Locate an unvisited frozen river or frozen ocean biome and teleport near it. Do not teleport into the middle of it.

  • Walk, run, or boat over to where the ice starts.

  • Place a boat on the ice and use it. The longer the stretch of ice it is used on, the more likely it will reproduce.

Expected Results:

As in 1.19.73, boats and chestboats should remain in the world no matter how fast the player moves across the ice.

Observed Results:

As seen in the attached video, a boat will disappear multiple times when a chunk that has not been visited yet is occupied. There also appears to be some issue with ice blocks temporarily disappearing when a new boat is placed down when the world generator is attempting to catch up.

Additional Notes:

While this example is in a brand-new world in the process of generating (which seems to cause it to happen more often) it can also happen in a world which has been played for a while where the world generator thread has caught up to the set render distance. Any time a boat is used in a newly visited chunk on ice there is a chance the boat and its contents may be lost.

The world used in the example video is also attached.

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media]
[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO

This issue occurs when a boat enters a chunk with issue MCPE-167185. I can confirm, although this is actually another manifestation of MCPE-167185. This can be reproduce in any world, anywhere (very easy in a cold biome on ice).

migrated

This is happening to me too, I've lost dozens of boats to this issue now...

MCExplorer44

I haven't been able to reproduce this in 1.19.80 on three new worlds, so it may be fixed in the stable release. However, it is still occurring in 1.20.0.22 Preview.

migrated

I can still reproduce this on the latest 1.19.81. Constantly happens; I can barely ride a boat for 15 seconds on ice before it disappears, and sometimes sticks me below the ice, too.

MCExplorer44

A quick update: On a 1.20.0.25 world a boat disappeared on water. So, the issue can still occur on water as well as ice, however the water occurrence is very rare. The good news is that on both ice and water exiting and reloading the world usually allows the boat to reappear, with the items intact if it is a chest boat.

migrated

This has happened to me virtually every time I'm taking a boat across stretches of water on the most recent preview, on any world I create. It seemed to happen more quickly when I was holding a map but that might be me projecting.

 

A quick capture: https://youtu.be/lXetBeViDxk

MCExplorer44

It is "fixed" in 1.20.10.21 in that using a boat on ice causes the game to pause and/or warp instead of disappearing. That is better than losing the boat, but I'm concerned how the server-side of Minecraft Bedrock has become so slow in updating new chunks that are fully visible yet cannot be operated within.

migrated

I just had this happen to me. I am on version 1.20.1 on Nintendo switch. I was on water in a previously explored chunk but slowly loading chunk. My chesyboat disappeared. I have relaoded the game, but I have not found my boat. Does it usually reappear where it was lost? Or where you entered it? 

MCExplorer44

(Unassigned)

1009068

Confirmed

Windows

Windows 10 Pro 22H2

boat, boat-with-chest

1.20.10.20 Preview, 1.20.0.25 Preview, 1.20.0.20 Preview, 1.19.80.24 Preview, 1.19.80.23 Preview, 1.20.0.22 Preview, 1.20.0.21 Preview, 1.20.0.24 Preview

1.20.10.21 Preview, 1.20.10

Retrieved