mojira.dev
MCPE-178882

Bogged has the same attack interval as normal skeletons and strays and not in parity with Java

When testing the bogged attack interval, it is noticable that the bogged has the same attack interval as skeletons and strays. This is evident as the bogged.json behavior file has the exact lines of code with skeletons and strays.

Step to Reproduce

  1. Put the bogged inside the box with a roof on top of it

  2. Put the skeleton or stray on the other box

  3. Get a shield

  4. Switch to survival mode

  5. Use your shield to defend yourself from the arrows

  6. Watch how long the attack interval goes

  7. Repeat the steps on skeleton and try to compare
    ❌ The attack interval is the same as the skeleton and not in parity with Java.

The lines of codes of the bogged.json behavior file:

[media]

Bedrock:

[media]


Java:

[media]

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 3

[media][media][media]

Evidently, the bogged.json behavior file was copy-pasted from the stray.json behavior file and edited without accounting for the fact that skeleton and strays use mele attacks when underwater, as stated it the 1.5 changelog:

  • Skeletons and Strays will switch from ranged to melee attacks while underwater and switch back when out of water

Therefore the ranged_attack component that was inserted into the bogged components, which contains the 3.5 s interval, actually does nothing at all, because it is overwritten by the attack component groups at spawn.

Evidently, the bogged.json behavior file was copy-pasted from the stray.json behavior file and edited without accounting for the fact that skeleton and strays use mele attacks when underwater, as stated it the 1.5 changelog:

  • Skeletons and Strays will switch from ranged to melee attacks while underwater and switch back when out of water

Therefore the ranged_attack component that was inserted into the bogged components, which contains the 3.5 s interval, actually does nothing at all, because it is overwritten by the attack component groups at spawn.

lillybeacon

(Unassigned)

1188744

Confirmed

Multiple

vanilla-parity

1.21.0.20 Preview, 1.20.70.24 Preview

1.21.0.22 Preview, 1.21.0

Retrieved