mojira.dev
MCPE-183225

/locate structure trial_chambers output text is not grammaticaly correct

steps to reproduce..

use /locate to find a Trial Chamber

see the output text reading "The nearest Trial Chambers is at ..."

expect proper English, "The nearest Trial Chamber is at..."
or "The nearest Trial Chambers are at..."

Attachments

Comments 5

This may be intended and grammatically correct, since "Trial Chambers" is a proper noun. Compare a shopping mall name "The Shoppes..." or a spa named "The Baths..." We wouldn't say "The Baths are my favorite places." We would say, "The Baths is my favorite place."

Or compare "Ocean Ruins" and "Trail Ruins" in-game.

Since it's not The Trial Chambers I feel that's kind of a poor comparison because it's yet a different context and it also oversimplifies a nuanced aspect of grammar. But it may be so. How can we know for sure? Many instances of inconsistent pluralization have been corrected in the past.

BTW here is a list of some instances in videos, posts and articles where Mojang specifically uses Trial Chamber when referring to just one of the new structures specifically in a singular manner.

https://youtu.be/ONs7kTlqGw4?t=104
https://youtu.be/bBr8BBrk1v8?t=33
https://youtu.be/8jwAtfyxhlk?t=144
https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/trial-chambers-first-peek
https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/composing-trial-chambers
https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/introducing-mace-and-ominous-events
https://www.minecraft.net/en-us/article/trial-chamber-prepping
https://x.com/Minecraft/status/1798023306714771656
https://x.com/Minecraft/status/1798730986227896483
https://x.com/Mega_Spud/status/1727382848301412768
https://x.com/Mega_Spud/status/1801294572632338640
https://x.com/MinecraftES/status/1798033415251607730
https://x.com/CornerHardMC/status/1804245055915593792
https://x.com/minecraftjapan/status/1741353498518671366

Not to mention The Advancement "Minecraft: Trial(s) Edition" has the description: "Step foot in a Trial Chamber"

The bug was confirmed; Mojang will decide whether this is intentional or not.

Thank you Jarl  🙂

Brian

(Unassigned)

1264124

Confirmed

Multiple

1.21.10.24 Preview, 1.21.0, 1.21.1 Hotfix

Retrieved