mojira.dev
MCPE-185285

Hoppers now locked with detector rail above them

Before the 1.21.20 update, it used to be possible to have detector rail above a hopper and using a comparator, detect when a minecart was empty as a result of sitting on the hopper so additional actions could be taken... like moving the minecart along. This no longer works. It appears that the detector rail now locks the hopper as soon as the minecart land on it meaning the hopper won't empty the minecart meaning the minecart will sit there forever.

Comments 5

Confirmed.

Steps to reproduce:
1. Place a hopper
2. Put a detector rail on top
3. Place a hopper minecart or chest minecart on top of detector rail
4. Put items inside minecart

Expected Result: 

  • Items will empty the minecart into the hopper and travel on

Actual Result:

  • Items stay inside the minecart

To my knowledge detector rails have always worked this way with hoppers, so in order to make a minecart-based filter you would need to offset the detector rail from the hopper in some way. Do you have any video of a setup working as you describe from before the update?

See also MC-9218, which was resolved as duplicate of MC-7178.

I am mistaken and @GoldenHelmet is correct. My previous build had the comparator on the hopper below and did not use a detector rail. You can close this.

I am mistaken and @GoldenHelmet is correct. My previous build had the comparator on the hopper below and did not use a detector rail. You can close this.

Thanks for the clarification. Resolving as Working As Intended based on the reports mentioned in my previous comment.

blue0rbit

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Multiple

Xbox Series X, Windows 10 PC

1.21.20

Retrieved