mojira.dev
MCPE-20977

Horse and Rider Can Take Damage As Soon As Player Mounts

Verification builds:
1.1.0.0

Summary:
Horses somehow die as soon as a player tries to mount them. They also seem to randomly take damage at other times.

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Tame a horse and Equip with saddle

  2. Ride the horse, dismount, then mount the horse again

  3. It has a high chance of dying randomly

Observed Results:
Horse takes damage or dies when the player mounts. Also has a chance to take damage when equipped with a saddle.

Expected Results:
Horses should not take damage from mounting, or normal riding

Screenshots/Videos attached: Yes
Youtube

[media]

Notes:

  • This may be a regression of an earlier bug whereby clients would cause horse damage by dismounting and jumping (eg MCPE-15218)

  • Horses also appear to take damage if you mount them and then equip a saddle

  • If the horse has received fall damage previously, it almost guarantees that it will take further damage when the player mounts it.

  • Test world attached

Linked issues

MCPE-22527 When I unleash and get on my horse in Survival, My Hearts and My Horses Hearts Drop Resolved MCPE-22528 When I unleash and Get On My Horse, It's Hearts and My Hearts Drop Resolved MCPE-22561 Horses Die/Take Damage Resolved MCPE-22615 When getting on a horse/donkey/mule it hurts them sometimes. Resolved MCPE-22686 If you equip a saddle or armor while on the horse it will take and give damage, and or die Resolved

Attachments

Comments 29

[media][media][media]

Invalid, This is for Pocket Edition Bugs Only , and that video and screenshot are of PC edition.

Invalid, This is for Pocket Edition Bugs Only , and that video and screenshot are of PC edition.

@unknown, this is a valid bug and it exists in MCPE. The video and the screenshots are not from the Java edition. Looking through your other comments, please refrain from commenting on bugs unless you have something to add that might help us solve the problem.

@unknown, this is a valid bug and it exists in MCPE. The video and the screenshots are not from the Java edition. Looking through your other comments, please refrain from commenting on bugs unless you have something to add that might help us solve the problem.

19 more comments

Ok you updated the title, but its not damage its instant death for players.

I've lost two horses today and died myself once. I died as soon as I tried to mount the horse. I'm not sure if this is always the case, but it seems to happen most when I am moving forward and mount while still holding the W key. I don't think a horse has died if I move next to it, stop and then mount, not 100% sure about that. Still needs fixed obviously, but something for others to try to see if it's only when you are moving forward and mount that it happens.

Windows 10 edition, v1.1.5

I've lost two horses today and died myself once. I died as soon as I tried to mount the horse. I'm not sure if this is always the case, but it seems to happen most when I am moving forward and mount while still holding the W key. I don't think a horse has died if I move next to it, stop and then mount, not 100% sure about that. Still needs fixed obviously, but something for others to try to see if it's only when you are moving forward and mount that it happens.

Windows 10 edition, v1.1.5

Fixed in 1.2.0.25.

Fixed in 1.2.0.25.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Windows

horse

1.1.0.0, 1.1.0.9, 1.1.0.55, 1.1.3.52, 1.2.0.2, 1.1.5.0, 1.2.0.15, 1.2.0.22

1.2.0.25

Retrieved